.
[This text was originally published as an introduction to the Taking Care section of Truth is Concrete: A Handbook for Artistic Strategies in Real Politics.]
In my book Revenge Fantasies of the Politically Dispossessed, I wrote about a group of activists who attend something referred to only as “the meetings.” What exactly the meetings are is never made entirely clear. However, a few things are explained. The meetings take place in a dystopian near future in which the activists in attendance have good reason to fear that, if they were to engage in effective acts of protest or civil disobedience, they would be arrested, tortured and perhaps killed. Their weekly gatherings are therefore a kind of refuge from this harsh reality. A place to talk, reflect, attempt to re-invent the left and prepare for a time when activism will be effective once again. When that time comes, because of the ongoing discussions that make up the meetings, they will have considered all options and be ready. Many readers saw these meetings as a satire on the ineffectiveness of the current left, but this was definitely not my intention. (In fact, at the end of the book, I break the fourth wall to explicitly state that I do not want the book to be read in only this manner.) The idea for the meetings had far more to do with my own personal frustration, with looking at the desperate state of the world and not knowing what to do, where to start, how real long-term change might begin and continue.
I remember first reading The Critique of Cynical Reason by Peter Sloterdijk, how I was fascinated by the concept of ‘enlightened false consciousness’, that we can clearly see all the structural inequalities we take part in perpetrating but still do little or nothing to change them. Or, on a slightly different register, I often think of an anecdote I once heard about Charles Mingus, who regularly began his concerts by playing the Duke Ellington standard Can’t Get Started. When asked why, he would apparently reply: ‘because that’s my problem in life, I can’t get started.’ All of this is a way of speaking around the fact that I have enormous sympathy for, and curiosity about, anyone who can get started. Who finds ways to break the inertia of relative privilege and set off on the endless and impossible task of improving the world. I don’t feel qualified to judge what might be more, or less, effective strategies in such matters. I fear that ‘the road to hell is paved with good intentions’ but, at the same time, also embody a much greater fear of my own ineffective paralysis.
We might say that all of the texts and projects in the following chapter take place on the other side of the line from where I stand. I am on this side of the line, along with much of the world’s population, where I’m definitely not doing enough (if I’m doing anything at all), and they are on the other side, where they are doing at least something, if not quite a bit more than that. On the other side of the line many strategies are invented and become possible. From WochenKlauser’s “concrete improvements of existing social circumstances” to Minerva Cuevas’s offering of “unexpected products”; from Michal Murin’s rehabilitation of his old friend Milan Adamčiak, assisting him from homelessness towards a renewed artistic practice, to Christoph Schlingensief’s equal treatment of superstar and differently abled performers; from the vacuum cleaner’s act of starting his own mental health institution and detaining himself within it to the necessary design-based paradigm shift that is Permaculture.
Again and again, I feel I am reading about events a little bit further along the path than I am. (Or, since I don’t particularly believe in progress, a little bit further around the circle that will endlessly continue unless our complete extinction cuts its short.) This feeling reminds me of the well-known last lines from Rilke about gazing at the Archaic Torso of Apollo: “for here there is no place
/ that does not see you. You must change your life.” It might be a simplified reading, but I have always seen these lines to mean that experiencing great art leads towards the realization that the way one is living is not nearly enough. ‘You must change your life’ doesn’t suggest that there is only one right answer, only one possible change, a right way and a wrong way and you must choose correctly. It is more about opening possibilities, opening up a window and letting in some air, wondering anew what can and cannot become part of our more general reality.
Notions such as care, kindness and compassion might help us find a basis for where such personal shifts can take place. Here we are in a territory of fragile humanism, about as far away from the ‘no future’ punk rock nihilism that was one of my personal entry points into art and creativity. If I can get past my anxiety that all punks become boring hippies in the end, I can see that conceptual strategies that allow for more generous social relations, to put it rather bluntly, often feel good when you take part in them. In their book On Kindness, Adam Phillips and Barbara Taylor suggest that Freudian or Hobbesian conceptions of people as inherently selfish or cruel turn our gaze away from something we already know: that behaving with kindness towards others occurs continuously, on all levels of society, and is in fact highly pleasurable. We are capable of selfishness but equally capable of generosity. The suggestion that we are not, or that one quality is more prominent in human nature than the other, is little more than propaganda for selfishness.
The strategies suggested in this chapter are varied, at times in conflict with each other, very much open to every kind of criticism. When you mix art and politics you open yourself up to a barrage of difficult questions from all sides: that the work is not political enough, that it takes the wrong political position, is naïve, is only a band aid on the problem it seeks to address. Because so many projects along these lines step outside of the safety of an autonomous artistic position, the grounds upon which they can be criticized become increasingly unstable. If I criticize a painting or a novel, the forms my criticism might take are fairly well established and, most of the time, reasonable limits are adhered to. But if I criticize an art project in which addicted, homeless sex workers and politicians are placed together on a boat in order to engage in dialogue, other levels of questioning rapidly, often confusingly, arise. How do I feel about the rights of sex workers? How do I understand sex work in relation to other kinds of work? How do I feel about activists (or artists) engaging with the state? How do I understand the social role of the state? Is it possible, in a short time, to set the parameters for a long-term solution to such a complex, ongoing problem? Where does charity end and empowerment begin? For me, such works have multiple agency: they assist the people more directly involved in the situation while at the same time opening a space in the imagination, suggesting that every social problem has multiple imaginative solutions if only we change our habits of thought.
Of course, changing our habits of thought is not nearly enough. Capitalism is a way of thinking, but is also a system that enriches the lives of few at the expense of the lives of many. To state the obvious: where there is suffering, most likely there is also economic profit. I suggested earlier that ‘kindness towards others occurs continuously, on all levels of society.’ I believe this to be true on an interpersonal level, but it does little to ameliorate the fact that structural inequality will put profit before kindness each and every time. If we start with the metaphor that I am on one side of a line, and on the other side are those who have taken at least the first step towards making small or large improvements; we might also suggest that along with me, on this side of the line, are many who take a considerably more vicious self-interest in maintaining the current status quo, who are working towards building up this metaphorical line into a totalitarian-capitalist prison from which they hope we will never escape. (And who likely wouldn’t put the matter in these specific terms.) Still, obsessing over these cruelties will get us nowhere. We are clearly not going to solve all the problems of the world in one fell swoop. Perhaps the only way is to start is as close to ourselves as possible, one small step after another, working towards situations in which possibilities might increase over time, looking around and feeling where our natural desire to care might be put to best use.
Criticality has become such an unquestioned staple of theory and art. However, it seems to me, a caring attitude does not require us to call upon our most critical selves. A critical outlook is often a defensive position, a desire to rip off the veil of surface appearance and get to the real stuff underneath. Yet not all truths are hidden. At times, surface appearances might be speaking to us so clearly and directly that, obsessed with what else might be there, we do not hear them. An art project that helps a friend in need, a friend who has fallen on hard times might, in offering another alternative, reveal some of the hardness present in this constant need for greater critical insight. To see someone in need, to try to help them, does not require the sophisticated critical apparatus that is so often celebrated as the only basis for complex thought. It only requires a belief that change is possible, the very belief that certain strains of critical thinking so often undermine.
Coming full circle, returning to Revenge Fantasies of the Politically Dispossessed, I can see now that part of the problem, part of the shortcomings within my own thinking, can be found in the title, since the characters in Revenge Fantasies are not truly dispossessed. They are dispossessed in the same way I feel myself to be, as a reasonably privileged, straight white male living in a wealthy country (Canada) currently being run by a government I completely disagree with. I have a certain amount of power that I could direct towards social change but cannot feel exactly what this power is or how I might use it, what other people I might form coalitions with and what specific issues we could organize around. I feel myself to be dispossessed but I don’t see how to bring myself into solidarity with those even more dispossessed than me. If I were to do so, it seems I would be setting off on an unknown path: most likely some (or many) of the people around me would change, as might my worldview. What are the things closest to me to which I can most usefully contribute? How does my misguided sense of dispossession, of alienation, prevent me from doing so? How does it short-circuit my compassion?
By each dealing with one small, yet specific, situation (and in the process bringing themselves closer to it), the projects and desires in this chapter remind us that focusing on immediate concerns, caring about someone or something within reach, can be a way of grounding ourselves. Reality is never just one thing. Luc Boltanski writes: “Reality suffers from a species of inherent fragility, such that the reality of reality must incessantly be reinforced in order to endure.” So many of the images and words that surround us continuously enforce and suggest the idea that, as Thatcher famously pronounced, ‘there is no alternative.’ There is certainly no heaven on earth we will all someday achieve. But there are as many alternatives as we are able to imagine, little pinpricks of hope, shifting moments for potential change. All we need to do is step over the line, take the first step. I wonder if some day I might.
.
February 12, 2016
We need a different...
.
We need a different vision of the world. A vision in which our survival depends on our symbiotic interdependence with other living things. A world in which, yes, we eat things, but other things also eat us.
.
We need a different vision of the world. A vision in which our survival depends on our symbiotic interdependence with other living things. A world in which, yes, we eat things, but other things also eat us.
.
February 1, 2016
Allison Hargreaves and David Jefferess Quote
.
How might we begin to imagine reconciliation beyond inclusion or loss – and instead as a transformed order of social relations? How might we come to recognize models for this transformation in what we typically understand as closed chapters or barriers? These models are articulated in treaty agreements and other nation-to-nation relations as understood in Indigenous traditions of diplomacy. Whether bonds of territorial, commercial, or political alliance and exchange, these pacts are ones for which we all inherit responsibility – Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples alike. When we, as settlers, misunderstand treaties as the lawful means by which Indigenous peoples “gave up” land for settlement and exploitative development, we legitimize what is in fact a history of theft and dispossession; when we misapprehend our position as one of inevitable ascendancy and belonging, we efface what might more productively be understood as one of profound failure: the failure to uphold historical agreements governing peaceful interactions between sovereign political bodies and their citizens. Against the nation-to-nation model, the story of “inclusion” and of “accommodation” has become the official story that gets told about our relation to one another, and about how reconciliation might work as “the ‘new’ way for Canada to relate to Indigenous people”. This is a continuation of colonial violence, as well as a dangerous violation of our own capacity to imagine and enact something different.
And so I think about barricades: the barricade as apparent threat, the barricade as unfathomable assertion, the barricade as the unwanted obstacle that stretches to its limits the tenuous fantasy of settler belonging. What if we instead understood the barricade – both as a physical barrier and as a practice of symbolic signification – less as an obstacle and threat, and more as something erected to protect “all of us”? In her recent interview alongside activist-thinkers Russell Diabo and Lisa Monchalin, non-Indigenous Idle No More activist Sheelah McLean gives the example of grassroots land protection struggles from Oka to Grassy Narrows and observes that, through such struggles and their mainstream representation, “The Canadian public are socialized to believe that barricades are violent”. As sites of seemingly irreconcilable conflict between Indigenous and non-Indigenous communities, the barricade is mistaken in the mainstream as the violent embodiment of this impasse rather than an opportunity for its transcendence. After all, there is no violence inherent to the barricade itself; its threat stems from its capacity to highlight the violence inherent in the colonial nation-state. Like the example of the Buffalo Commons map, then, the barricade could provide an opening onto a different relationship to land and to one another – one that both acknowledges the violence of settlement and resource extraction, and that affirms shared obligations to care-take the land for the wellbeing of future generations.
- Allison Hargreaves and David Jefferess, Always Beginning: Imagining Reconciliation Beyond Inclusion or Loss
This quote is taken from the remarkable collection The Land We Are: Artists and Writers Unsettle the Politics of Reconciliation
.
How might we begin to imagine reconciliation beyond inclusion or loss – and instead as a transformed order of social relations? How might we come to recognize models for this transformation in what we typically understand as closed chapters or barriers? These models are articulated in treaty agreements and other nation-to-nation relations as understood in Indigenous traditions of diplomacy. Whether bonds of territorial, commercial, or political alliance and exchange, these pacts are ones for which we all inherit responsibility – Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples alike. When we, as settlers, misunderstand treaties as the lawful means by which Indigenous peoples “gave up” land for settlement and exploitative development, we legitimize what is in fact a history of theft and dispossession; when we misapprehend our position as one of inevitable ascendancy and belonging, we efface what might more productively be understood as one of profound failure: the failure to uphold historical agreements governing peaceful interactions between sovereign political bodies and their citizens. Against the nation-to-nation model, the story of “inclusion” and of “accommodation” has become the official story that gets told about our relation to one another, and about how reconciliation might work as “the ‘new’ way for Canada to relate to Indigenous people”. This is a continuation of colonial violence, as well as a dangerous violation of our own capacity to imagine and enact something different.
And so I think about barricades: the barricade as apparent threat, the barricade as unfathomable assertion, the barricade as the unwanted obstacle that stretches to its limits the tenuous fantasy of settler belonging. What if we instead understood the barricade – both as a physical barrier and as a practice of symbolic signification – less as an obstacle and threat, and more as something erected to protect “all of us”? In her recent interview alongside activist-thinkers Russell Diabo and Lisa Monchalin, non-Indigenous Idle No More activist Sheelah McLean gives the example of grassroots land protection struggles from Oka to Grassy Narrows and observes that, through such struggles and their mainstream representation, “The Canadian public are socialized to believe that barricades are violent”. As sites of seemingly irreconcilable conflict between Indigenous and non-Indigenous communities, the barricade is mistaken in the mainstream as the violent embodiment of this impasse rather than an opportunity for its transcendence. After all, there is no violence inherent to the barricade itself; its threat stems from its capacity to highlight the violence inherent in the colonial nation-state. Like the example of the Buffalo Commons map, then, the barricade could provide an opening onto a different relationship to land and to one another – one that both acknowledges the violence of settlement and resource extraction, and that affirms shared obligations to care-take the land for the wellbeing of future generations.
- Allison Hargreaves and David Jefferess, Always Beginning: Imagining Reconciliation Beyond Inclusion or Loss
This quote is taken from the remarkable collection The Land We Are: Artists and Writers Unsettle the Politics of Reconciliation
.
Labels:
Allison Hargreaves,
David Jefferess,
Quotes,
The Land We Are
Sandra Semchuk Quote
.
You knew James [Nicholas], my late husband, a Cree writer, actor and government liaison for the Nisichawayasihk Cree Nation. None of the video or photographic works that he and I did in the name of reconciliation for fifteen years ever seemed to sit still. I would think we were doing one thing and, unexpectedly, the work would turn upside down. I remember James and I talking about generosity with an elder at Waterhen Lake Cree Nation. I understood then that white government people turned things upside down by making themselves the generous ones. Generosity and power are so connected. I asked James if he could teach me how to say, in Cree, thank you for sharing the land. He responded, “You don’t understand. Sharing is the law. The land owns itself.”
- Sandra Semchuk
This quote can be found in the remarkable collection The Land We Are: Artists and Writers Unsettle the Politics of Reconciliation
.
You knew James [Nicholas], my late husband, a Cree writer, actor and government liaison for the Nisichawayasihk Cree Nation. None of the video or photographic works that he and I did in the name of reconciliation for fifteen years ever seemed to sit still. I would think we were doing one thing and, unexpectedly, the work would turn upside down. I remember James and I talking about generosity with an elder at Waterhen Lake Cree Nation. I understood then that white government people turned things upside down by making themselves the generous ones. Generosity and power are so connected. I asked James if he could teach me how to say, in Cree, thank you for sharing the land. He responded, “You don’t understand. Sharing is the law. The land owns itself.”
- Sandra Semchuk
This quote can be found in the remarkable collection The Land We Are: Artists and Writers Unsettle the Politics of Reconciliation
.
Labels:
Quotes,
Sandra Semchuk,
The Land We Are
January 29, 2016
About Something Fragment
.
I know there is something I’m searching for in art but when I try to identify it, it seems almost impossible to do so accurately. I identify my desire as a desire for art that’s “about something,” and contrast it with a feeling I so often have seeing art that’s “not about anything.” I also, at times, refer to this art that’s “about something” as art that’s connected to the world, to life, to everyday life, to life outside of art, to politics or to emancipatory struggles. And I contrast it with art that’s “not about anything” which I relate to formalism, empty formalism, technology, technique, art about art, art that focuses on a particular art historical referent or figure or art that tries to be purely in the moment. However, none of this says anything about in what way I want this art to be “about something,” and I suppose that’s where the problems actually begin. Because, for me, this being “about something” also has to be fully, yet ambiguously, integrated into the ways this art is and becomes art.
[Unfinished.]
.
I know there is something I’m searching for in art but when I try to identify it, it seems almost impossible to do so accurately. I identify my desire as a desire for art that’s “about something,” and contrast it with a feeling I so often have seeing art that’s “not about anything.” I also, at times, refer to this art that’s “about something” as art that’s connected to the world, to life, to everyday life, to life outside of art, to politics or to emancipatory struggles. And I contrast it with art that’s “not about anything” which I relate to formalism, empty formalism, technology, technique, art about art, art that focuses on a particular art historical referent or figure or art that tries to be purely in the moment. However, none of this says anything about in what way I want this art to be “about something,” and I suppose that’s where the problems actually begin. Because, for me, this being “about something” also has to be fully, yet ambiguously, integrated into the ways this art is and becomes art.
[Unfinished.]
.
January 27, 2016
Monomaniacal: A Confession
.
Twice in the past month someone has called me monomaniacal. I believe it was the first two times I ever even heard the word. I barely noticed the first time, it was only the repetition that caught my attention. Basically, what I think they both meant is that I’m completely focused on my artistic work, that my relation to it is a kind of tunnel vision (which isn’t necessarily the technical definition of the word monomaniacal.) Others have certainly complained about this to me in the past, and I’m sure it’s something I admit to from time to time, but for the most part it’s an aspect of my life I do my best to hide. I definitely feel there’s something shameful about it, that it doesn’t reflect especially well on me as a human being. I also feel I must somehow be admitting to it more frequently these days. Maybe it’s even becoming more true over time. Part of this is a particularly intense feeling that I will die soon, and I should finish up these last few projects before I go. (I don’t have a fatal disease or anything. It’s just a feeling that I’m getting closer to the end. Perhaps only wishful thinking.) (Even more often I have the feeling that I’ve already died. A ghost wandering through a world that no longer concerns it.) As I get older, it also becomes harder to pretend that I’m interested in things when I’m actually not. I still feel an enormous curiosity about art and the world, but at the same time it does seem that certain matters in my life are more or less settled (i.e. I’m not suddenly going to develop some great interest in basketball, or cooking, or other people, or religion, or have a desire to own a car, or want children.) Then I shift to another register, since the word ‘monomaniacal’ reminds me of other recent, prominent dilemmas. This feeling that I would like to be doing less, but actually can’t stop, keep doing more. I’ve started saying I’m semi-retired and yet, at the same time, it seems to be less true than ever. (I just finished one book and already I’m half way through the first draft of another.) I wonder if being over-productive is only a bad habit. In this sense, this word ‘monomaniacal’ hits me like a punch. As I’ve frequently written: I have this overwhelming feeling of failure, and often wonder if this feeling of failure is the main engine driving me. Over-production, failure, bad habits, ongoing personal and artistic history. Ambition and the desire for success. Hunger for praise. Talent or the inability to do anything else. Full of questions and doubts but nonetheless going with things that seem to work. Full of doubts but doing things anyway. A need for money, living hand-to-mouth. Not knowing how to do anything else and realizing that now, in the time that’s left, I will most likely never learn. Is this what it means to be an artist?
.
Twice in the past month someone has called me monomaniacal. I believe it was the first two times I ever even heard the word. I barely noticed the first time, it was only the repetition that caught my attention. Basically, what I think they both meant is that I’m completely focused on my artistic work, that my relation to it is a kind of tunnel vision (which isn’t necessarily the technical definition of the word monomaniacal.) Others have certainly complained about this to me in the past, and I’m sure it’s something I admit to from time to time, but for the most part it’s an aspect of my life I do my best to hide. I definitely feel there’s something shameful about it, that it doesn’t reflect especially well on me as a human being. I also feel I must somehow be admitting to it more frequently these days. Maybe it’s even becoming more true over time. Part of this is a particularly intense feeling that I will die soon, and I should finish up these last few projects before I go. (I don’t have a fatal disease or anything. It’s just a feeling that I’m getting closer to the end. Perhaps only wishful thinking.) (Even more often I have the feeling that I’ve already died. A ghost wandering through a world that no longer concerns it.) As I get older, it also becomes harder to pretend that I’m interested in things when I’m actually not. I still feel an enormous curiosity about art and the world, but at the same time it does seem that certain matters in my life are more or less settled (i.e. I’m not suddenly going to develop some great interest in basketball, or cooking, or other people, or religion, or have a desire to own a car, or want children.) Then I shift to another register, since the word ‘monomaniacal’ reminds me of other recent, prominent dilemmas. This feeling that I would like to be doing less, but actually can’t stop, keep doing more. I’ve started saying I’m semi-retired and yet, at the same time, it seems to be less true than ever. (I just finished one book and already I’m half way through the first draft of another.) I wonder if being over-productive is only a bad habit. In this sense, this word ‘monomaniacal’ hits me like a punch. As I’ve frequently written: I have this overwhelming feeling of failure, and often wonder if this feeling of failure is the main engine driving me. Over-production, failure, bad habits, ongoing personal and artistic history. Ambition and the desire for success. Hunger for praise. Talent or the inability to do anything else. Full of questions and doubts but nonetheless going with things that seem to work. Full of doubts but doing things anyway. A need for money, living hand-to-mouth. Not knowing how to do anything else and realizing that now, in the time that’s left, I will most likely never learn. Is this what it means to be an artist?
.
January 25, 2016
David Garneau Quote
.
Prior to this gathering, I was not optimistic about the social engineering called Truth and Reconciliation. When first asked to work in this area more than five years ago by Jonathan Dewar, I rejected the idea. Even before seeing the testimony process firsthand, I felt that the principles of the formal TRC project continue the colonial enterprise. Individual payouts for personal testimony – rather than nation-to-nation settlements – are designed to bypass Treaty relationships, to divide and conquer. While the aggressive assimilation spearheaded by Indian Residential Schools targeted children, it was designed to ruin communities, past, present, future. The money, and the public raking up of this pain, has caused a great deal of (mostly unreported) devastation to individuals, families, and communities. I remain convinced that the official Truth and Reconciliation is primarily a non-Indigenous project designed to reconcile settlers with their dark history in order that they might live in this territory more comfortably and exploit these lands more thoroughly.
“Re-conciliation” assumes that Indigenous people and settlers once had a conciliatory relationship; that all is needed is Indigenous absolution for harmony to be restored. But there is no halcyon moment to recover, only the on-going colonial condition to become conscious of and resist. This cannot occur in the TRC bubble of structured empathy, where the pressure on survivors to forgive is enormous. The first line of the TRC’s official mandate reads: “There is an emerging and compelling desire to put the events of the past behind us so that we can work towards a stronger and healthier future” (“Establishment”). Whose compelling desire? The cruelty of this construction is that it places the onus on survivors of these internment institutions to forgive both their absent abusers and the abstract state. Following the familiar colonial script, these people are narrated as obstacles that must be overcome if we are to move forwards “towards a stronger and healthier future.” The TRC’s emotionalist structure negates resistance, reason, and discourse. The TRC is a pain generator, a testimony and tear-stained tissue collector. The federal focus on Indian Residential Schools is an effort to personalize, cauterize, and distract notice away from larger issues. It aims to direct attention to the display of individual Indigenous suffering bodies, rather than the collective wholes that were betrayed. It attempts to pay off and/or “heal” these folks rather than negotiate with their nations. And it is designed to distract both Indigenous and non-Indigenous folks from larger ongoing issues of Canadian colonization and land (ab)use.
- David Garneau
This quote is taken from the remarkable collection The Land We Are: Artists and Writers Unsettle the Politics of Reconciliation
.
Prior to this gathering, I was not optimistic about the social engineering called Truth and Reconciliation. When first asked to work in this area more than five years ago by Jonathan Dewar, I rejected the idea. Even before seeing the testimony process firsthand, I felt that the principles of the formal TRC project continue the colonial enterprise. Individual payouts for personal testimony – rather than nation-to-nation settlements – are designed to bypass Treaty relationships, to divide and conquer. While the aggressive assimilation spearheaded by Indian Residential Schools targeted children, it was designed to ruin communities, past, present, future. The money, and the public raking up of this pain, has caused a great deal of (mostly unreported) devastation to individuals, families, and communities. I remain convinced that the official Truth and Reconciliation is primarily a non-Indigenous project designed to reconcile settlers with their dark history in order that they might live in this territory more comfortably and exploit these lands more thoroughly.
“Re-conciliation” assumes that Indigenous people and settlers once had a conciliatory relationship; that all is needed is Indigenous absolution for harmony to be restored. But there is no halcyon moment to recover, only the on-going colonial condition to become conscious of and resist. This cannot occur in the TRC bubble of structured empathy, where the pressure on survivors to forgive is enormous. The first line of the TRC’s official mandate reads: “There is an emerging and compelling desire to put the events of the past behind us so that we can work towards a stronger and healthier future” (“Establishment”). Whose compelling desire? The cruelty of this construction is that it places the onus on survivors of these internment institutions to forgive both their absent abusers and the abstract state. Following the familiar colonial script, these people are narrated as obstacles that must be overcome if we are to move forwards “towards a stronger and healthier future.” The TRC’s emotionalist structure negates resistance, reason, and discourse. The TRC is a pain generator, a testimony and tear-stained tissue collector. The federal focus on Indian Residential Schools is an effort to personalize, cauterize, and distract notice away from larger issues. It aims to direct attention to the display of individual Indigenous suffering bodies, rather than the collective wholes that were betrayed. It attempts to pay off and/or “heal” these folks rather than negotiate with their nations. And it is designed to distract both Indigenous and non-Indigenous folks from larger ongoing issues of Canadian colonization and land (ab)use.
- David Garneau
This quote is taken from the remarkable collection The Land We Are: Artists and Writers Unsettle the Politics of Reconciliation
.
Labels:
David Garneau,
Quotes,
The Land We Are
January 7, 2016
Contradictions and Paradoxes: Lene Berg and Jacob Wren
.
[This text was originally published in Fillip 19.]
In 2008, shortly after discovering her work, I wrote a text about Lene Berg for C Magazine entitled “Glad the CIA Is Immoral,” focusing on her project Gentlemen & Arseholes (2007) and how it spoke directly to so many of my ongoing concerns about art, how art may or may not become political. The text ended by going a bit over-the-top, with a last line that read: “Lene Berg is the artist I have been waiting for all of my life.”
In 2011, Lene and I collaborated on the project Big Brother Where Art Thou?, a work that took place entirely on Facebook and mixed reflections on George Orwell and his work with research into how the state security apparatus uses social media to monitor the lives of those who use it. Each day for one week we sat at our respective computers—Lene in Berlin, me in Montreal—and talked on Skype as we posted material on these themes in response to each other’s posts. The Brother Where Art Thou? Facebook page still exists, an archive of a moment in time before the recent NSA scandal broke, a period in which the possibility that governments might use Facebook to infiltrate the lives of its users still seemed more like vague Orwellian rumours than reality.
It is worth noting that Lene Berg often takes a historical footnote as the source material for her projects and employs her ensuing research to reveal paradoxes and gaps in how we see history and its relation to current predicaments, for example: how an anti-communist discourse promoting modernist artistic freedom laid the groundwork for our current, considerably less free cultural field. Her work suggests that consensus views of politics, history, sexuality, etc., are often misleading, that they reveal considerably more in what they exclude, in how they leave things out, than they are able to tell us about the machinations of the world or what happened in the past.
Our conversation took place over email.
—Jacob Wren
Jacob Wren: When I first discovered your work what struck me most was how concretely you addressed the relation between art and politics. I was wondering, since you address it quite often, if you have some general thoughts about how art and politics relate? And if your feelings around these questions changed at all in and around the Stalin by Picasso (2008) scandals, when your project examining a single 1953 drawing that Picasso made of Stalin – a project that consisted of a video, a series of drawings and three public banners – had the banners unexpectedly removed, I believe we can say censored, by the presenting institutions in both Oslo and in New York.
Lene Berg: There is no clear line between art and politics. But the relationship between the two is not static and it is not always easy to spot or to define. It is full of contradictions. It changes. It can also be very specific for certain situations, individuals, or institutions.
One of my starting points for the project Gentlemen & Arseholes was the feeling that I lived in a free world, but that, at the same time, there were very strict and definite limits to that freedom. The problem was, and is, that these limits are often so ingrained that they are not perceived as limits, but rather they are regarded as laws of nature. In the beginning of the project I was stunned by how manipulatively art and philosophy were used during the Cold War by the CIA and its allies. At the same time this confirmed that there is power in these fields. The beauty is that artistic power is different from political power, even if at certain times they can collide. Artistic power is about spreading ideas, and no one controls the impact of a film, a text, or an image completely—even when one funds them.
What happened with Stalin by Picasso confirmed just how contentious, in this sense how powerful, art can be, in many ways and on many levels, but the force of the reactions against it was much stronger than I could ever have imagined. The visual illiteracy of some of the criticism shocked me. Since then, I more and more have the feeling that we in the so-called West, or in the former West, live in a quite restricted and narrow cultural environment. What is discussed within an art context, in terms of what an image represents, for instance, has not reached a broader public and therefore has very little bearing outside of the art scene (for lack of a better word). Images printed in a newspaper or art shown in a public space are still to a high degree read as propaganda or illustrations. The public and the press can in general not deal with complexities or ambiguities. This is a democratic problem as it promotes stupidity, ignorance, and manipulation.
I find the definition of “political art” problematic. As I see it artworks that address political issues are not necessarily more political than other works, they often just look critical or political, like a style or a genre. A lot of left-wing art, for example, is merely reproducing ideas that are accepted and acclaimed in the social circles of the artists and curators distributing them. As they mainly illustrate established points of view the potential impact is minimal. I do not wish to illustrate my opinion in my work—on the contrary, I try to challenge and question my views. At the same time, there is of course a relationship between how I think and what I produce. There are no clear lines. And one has to remember that art and politics are on one level only words, two abstract categories that do not necessarily describe reality very accurately.
JW: There was the incredible irony that when Pablo Picasso first made the drawing of Joseph Stalin, it upset people because it was seen as tarnishing the image or memory of Stalin, but when you showed the exact same drawing in Oslo and New York people were upset because it was seen to praise him. These are both highly charged reactions. I wonder if a strong, immediate emotional reaction to an image might short circuit a more nuanced reading. If some of the same people who denounced your work might also be able to read images in a more complex way in other circumstances. Your work often heads directly for societal sore spots: political control of art, sex work, etc. You want to be in precarious territory, but once there you provide such a complex, nuanced perspective. How do you see this dynamic between emotionally charged material and a more critical view?
LB: As a matter of fact, I did not at all foresee that Stalin by Picasso would evoke such strong feelings, which in hindsight might seem naive. I thought some people would be provoked or annoyed by the fact that Picasso had made a portrait of Stalin and that this possibly would lead to discussions around art, independence, post-WWII battles, and maybe even about the myth of the lonely genius. But it turned out that Stalin was the problem, more than Picasso. And it was in fact not so much the image of Stalin that was a problem, even if that also created some of the anger, but his role in Western history. No one wanted that history back on the table. In other words I hit a sore spot, but not exactly the one I had aimed for.
But yes, I think you are right, very charged reactions are often a product of immediate emotional responses based on second-hand information. And one has of course very limited control over the reception of one’s own work, if at all. The interpretation is more often than not dependent on one or more middlemen or middlewomen—distributors, curators, critics, etc. When the general press/media is involved there is no way to control the presentation or the discussion. After all, news journalists tend to seek controversy, not meaning or content. The media-driven nature of the discussion somehow takes on a life of its own.
For instance, a stranger attacked me quite violently at a party once during the controversy around Stalin by Picasso. He accused me of being an egotistical artist trying to deliberately smear the labour party and hurt people to get PR for myself. He had only seen a photoshopped image in the paper and read the statement from the party secretary who took down the banners. Some time afterward he apologized through a common friend as he had realized that the project was much more and quite different from the impression he had gotten from the media.
So even if I am not afraid of controversy, and even like to deal with topics that potentially are controversial, I don’t really believe in simple provocation. It often has the consequence that people close themselves off and then nothing new can enter.
JW: It’s a striking moment, this hitting “a sore spot, but not exactly the one you had aimed for.” There’s always something electric when we hit the wrong targets, when the meaning of a given work gets away from the artist. Also something distressing.
Your film Kopfkino (2012) features eight women who work as dominatrix’s telling stories about their work, seated along a table reminiscent of the Last Super (perhaps also a twist on Judy Chicago’s The Dinner Party.) This is territory that could definitely offend a certain kind of person, maybe not someone in the art world, but certainly someone in the American religious right. In Kopfkino, I suspect the relation between art and politics is different than some of the other projects we’ve been discussing; that is, that it has more to do with giving these women an opportunity to speak. Was there anything the women in the film said that surprised you, or that was unexpected? From your perspective, what does it mean to have these women speaking for themselves about their work?
LB: The starting point for Kopfkino was actually questions more about storytelling and fiction than questions about sex workers or S&M. I got the idea after a dinner with one of the ladies where she told me about her work as a dominatrix. I was always interested in the function of stories, and how the structure of a story shapes the content and vice versa. Apart from being entertaining, stories are of course vehicles to spread ideas, knowledge, experience, and morality, as well as myths, lies, and propaganda. The stories Dunja Eckert-Jakobi told me that night were very concrete and very personal. Without having to force it, they automatically opened to so many charged and central themes, such as hierarchy, money, gender, social roles, and of course sex. I was also fascinated by the way she told her stories, how she described her clients and the situations, and how she built the narratives.
There is a lot of humour in the film, but some of the things the women talk about are so intricate and complex that most people have a hard time figuring them out. Such as the discussion about a pedophile client: Should one help him live out his fantasies in order to protect kids from him or will the staging of his fantasies actually make it easier for him to realize them afterward? This discussion is relevant for movie making as well as other artistic expressions. For instance, when you picture violent events, abuse, or discrimination, are you presenting a cathartic experience or are you in fact inspiring people to do the same, giving them visual examples of how it could be done as well as a structure, a story, that makes sense of such actions?
One of the themes in Kopfkino is the floating division between fiction and reality. Even if we believe we can separate the two, fiction and reality are intertwined in many ways and forms. One might say that fiction is reality as long as we believe in it. And as a culture Westerners live with a hard-to-handle cocktail: a fundamentally Christian morality on the one hand and on the other hand a capitalist ideology, which sooner or later accepts almost everything that is commercially successful even if it is morally suspect. Except maybe for prostitution, which is still illegal in most of the Western world. This fact was of course also important in the idea for Kopfkino and how to stage it. From the start I knew I wanted it to be about fiction; not fiction as the opposite of truth—on the contrary, fiction as a way of revealing something true, or perhaps rather something real. I wanted the women to speak as subjects and not as victims. I wanted to avoid stigmatization and pity. In a sense I wanted to normalize something that is regarded as bizarre and perverse. These women sell their time and their bodies, but most people do that in one way or another and I have a much bigger problem with intellectual prostitution than with what they do. Since they are dealing with things that sometimes are dangerous, sometimes disgusting, and often extremely demanding, they are forced to reflect upon their own responsibility and limits, including the role of money in their work. Does the fact that they are being paid mean that they have to deny their own pleasure? Is “a professional” not supposed to be fully present, just giving his or her services without using his or her own personality, judgment, or desire? Such questions are of course relevant far beyond the world of S&M.
JW: How do you think Kopfkino relates to feminism? In one sense, the women are empowered, have a lot of control over their lives and, within the film itself, on how their stories are told. But in another sense they are still employed by men. Do you think Kopfkino relates to feminism at all or is that a misleading way to watch the film?
LB: Even if I never try to illustrate my opinion or a specific theory in my work, I think Kopfkino fundamentally is a feminist film. But I have also met people who find it anti-feminist. It depends on how one defines feminism I suppose. And it is a tricky film to place within any category really. Some of the role-playing games described are very archaic and old-fashioned. Almost scarily so. You have to wonder how these often medieval hierarchies have survived through centuries, in the shape of sexual fantasies and desires. At the same time, the variety of female personalities, in spite of the clichés they are dressed up as, is impossible to overlook and adds other and unexpected dimensions to the picture.
I find it interesting that Kopfkino can be read in many different contexts and using different theories. The women’s stories are very rich and full of questions that are relevant to various discussions – about gender, sex, labour, power, and alienation, to mention a few. Then there is another level, which is about how they tell their stories and comment on each other’s experiences. And on another level there are questions about authenticity, staging, and reality, which lie in the way the film is shot and edited.
I personally find the mix of reality and fantasy in the stories themselves very intriguing. Since desire is one of the things one cannot fake, there is some sort of truth, or reality, to the role-playing games these women stage. There is also the aspect of shifting roles: that one individual has several possibilities to express herself or himself, including sexually. But one needs a stage, a setting to be able to go outside of one’s social role. S&M is one such scene. I also see several parallels between their profession and filmmaking. There is a certain degree of illusion and a lot of timing involved. These are hard to define skills, but they are central to human communication, to storytelling, and to acting.
What does it mean to play a role for money? Is it empowering to handle other people’s sexual desires or enslaving? I honestly don’t know, but I do not perceive these women as particularly oppressed. Some of them seem to be in possession of knowledge about their own sexuality and about sexual desire in general that I have seldom encountered in such a frank and non-idealized way. At the same time, I do think their work can be boring, degrading, and exhausting both for the mind and the body. Most of them also have other jobs or they study.
JW: I feel your work doesn’t play a game I often see in visual art: the artist keeping all the cards close to his or her chest, creating works that are unreadable without a certain amount of background information, often to be found in the catalogue or brochure. In your work, I often don’t need any other information apart from what I experience in the work itself. Do you agree with this assessment? How do you see this aspect of your practice? (Perhaps it also makes your work more difficult to write about because so much of what needs to be said has already been conveyed.) Might this directness also have something to do with your background in film?
LB: It is true that I like my works to be sort of self-contained, so that they can be seen without knowing the background discussion or my references. I try to avoid talking in codes or mystifying things, but my projects are often composed by contradictions and paradoxes, which may also make them hard to write about. When I start to work on an idea I often focus on the surface, what it will look and feel like. As the project develops this may change, but I like there to be a certain dynamic between the surface and the content, so that as one goes into the work ones perception of the surface will be altered and sometimes even completely changed in the process.
It is very likely that my background in film has shaped my way of working. Movies are in general expected to communicate immediately with everyone. This need tends to turn any content into the same kind of story or message, which is something I am trying to avoid at almost any cost. My method is probably most of all a result of the years I worked with the film company Hinden in Stockholm. We were a handful people working together on very different kinds of projects, from advertising to feature films, short films, art projects, etc. Sometimes I was directing, often not. Parallel to the practical work, which at times was quite hard and demanding, we discussed a lot of theoretical issues in relationship to what we were doing and producing. Without this mix of physical and practical work and the continuous discussions around it, I probably would have been a different person and artist.
JW: I’m still thinking about something you said earlier, about how we live “in a free world, but that, at the same time, there are very strict and definite limits to that freedom.” And how, over the past ten or so years, maybe since 9/11, my feelings around our apparent (Western) freedom have changed so much. How more and more it seems we’re no longer free to gather and protest, or how our confidence that we have privacy—for example, online or in an email—has lessened. And that the celebration of (illusory) Western freedom might have had more to do with the Cold War—with convincing the world that “democracy” was better than “communism”—than it did with any actual desire for, for example, free speech. (But then I think about McCarthyism, how little room for dissent there was during that period, and wonder if my sense of history is simply off.) Has your thinking around different kinds of freedom changed at all over the last ten or fifteen years? Do you think there’s been a significant recent shift?
LB: I had this feeling long before 9/11, but since then it has become more evident and tangible. Living off and on in New York has made it clear to me that a corporate worldview is more and more dominating. While politicians speak of pluralism and freedom, the preferred lifestyle is quite narrow and has very little tolerance for difference. Actually it is less tolerant or open now than in the 80’s when I was a teenager, which is quite surprising to me.
Sadly, what is going on now is not so different from the era of McCarthyism or pre-WWII: the law is used to suppress difference of opinion and to defend people of privilege. I suppose 9/11 made it easier to change the laws in this direction. The law is the key to rule the world, at least if you have the police and the courts to back it up, and the big corporations are better protected by the law than the individual at this point.
The West has so many blind spots in terms of what freedom actually means, or can mean, and very little consciousness about the actual conditions for freedom, or for democracy or pluralism for that matter. It seems to me that a lot of the challenges that were present at the beginning and middle of the last century are still with us. More and more often I experience how racist, sexist and nationalistic views are used as part of a social struggle as less privileged groups and individuals turn to white-supremacy, infantile nationalism or anti-gay ideas to oppose the liberal bourgeoisie, to use an old fashioned term.
JW: I now think my last question was too naive. (Though, at the same time, I’m always searching for ways to produce productive naiveté.) Something may have shifted with 9/11, but the history of Western unfreedom is such a long one. I’ve read a great deal of history, but often think not exactly that I don’t know history well enough (of course I don’t), but that I don’t feel history enough. And I did clearly feel the restrictions directly following 9/11, perhaps suggesting it’s not such an important even in generalized Western unfreedom, but was an important event within my own personal sense of it. (Much like Vietnam was a significant event for a previous generation.) With earlier works like The Weimar Conspiracy (2007) and The Drowned One (2008) you question how things enter history and what we actually know about them (versus what we think we know). Do you know how your interest in the paradoxes of writing and experiencing history first began? Can history be more or less objective? More recent projects seem to have moved away from the topic.
LB: This may sound strange, but for me history was never really my topic. I happened to discover some historical events that presented the possibility to deal with things that preoccupied me. As history is used to motivate present actions and ideas, turning and tossing historic events is a way to question the present perception and representation of things. Even if only indirectly.
I am interested in storytelling and the relationship between stories and the realities they depict. History is in a way our common story; it is used to shed light on the present. There are of course many ways to construct and tell stories, and depending on how they are told they will mean very different things and sometimes have very different consequences. That also goes for history.
Also, for some years I had problems funding my work, and I discovered that I could use found footage, archival material, collages, etc., to produce quite complex things for very little cash. It gave me a certain freedom for a while, and I will probably do projects like that again, but I needed to move on. Or actually: to move back to where I came from. I like teamwork, working with actors, sets, etc. That is what I started out doing and it has been a great pleasure to be able to return to that.
Even if my projects look different and seem to deal with very different topics, some themes run through them all. I don’t try to pin these themes down though—they are simply part of my thinking and doing however I work, for good and for bad. I like every project to have its own challenges, even its own style and expression. For me an idea for a new project is more about knowing how to work on it and how to define the elements out of which the final project will be constructed than knowing exactly what it will look like in the end.
JW: The kinds of contradictions and paradoxes in your work usually aren’t formal aspects of the work itself, aren’t contradictions you create. More often they are contradictions and paradoxes you discover in the world and then focus our attention on. In this sense your work needs to be as clear as possible in order to present the full complexity of nuance and questioning that real-life paradoxes generate. How do you see the dynamic in your work between clarity and paradox? Do you know why you’re attracted to these kinds of narratives?
LB: I seek clarity as much as possible, that is true. But I distrust one liners and beloved simplifications, or clichés, if you like. There are many mysteries in human relations and conditions, and things that are made up of contradictions and paradoxes seem real to me. Also they protect me from confirming the obvious and from reproducing automatic thinking.
The following may sound a bit pretentious but I believe the human mind is incapable of grasping the truth as it is. Not only because the truth is often cruel, but because our minds are not conditioned for it. I do believe there are facts that are beyond fiction, but they are very few and to understand them we need a system, a fiction, if you like. I believe fiction, in a broad sense of the word, is a human way of making sense. Fiction is not necessarily about lies, but neither is it about truth in an absolute sense. The question is not so much whether something is fiction or fact, but what kind of fiction it is and with what purpose it is being told, reproduced and repeated. I am interested not in disclosing another fact that can be added to the general story but in presenting my material in a form that adds something and possibly also questions a dominating fiction. Such as the macho myth around Picasso or the notion that there is no ideology in the present liberal democracies, just to mention two very general examples.
That said, I have to add that language is not of great help when I try to pin down these ideas. The words and notions used to define things like fact and fiction easily create some sort of mental labyrinth when you start to challenge them. Sometimes I enjoy being in such labyrinths, at least for a while. With a bit of experience I have learned how to get out of them, otherwise I would have gone mad a long time ago.
JW: Language can certainly complicate or obscure as easily as clarify. Tools for communication can easily flip over into defense mechanisms. But, for me, there are so many aspects of your projects that cut through art, that speak so clearly and directly to the world. Would you like this work to be less marginal?
LB: I think some of my projects relate to very small circles, such as Gentlemen & Arseholes and Dirty Young Loose (2013) whereas others, like Stalin by Picasso or Kopfkino, are projects with a much broader potential. I do not think that it is important that everything reaches everyone, but I do think the current distribution systems are limited by old-fashioned categories: a lot of things can’t reach an audience because they don’t fit established genres or boxes. At the same time, such distribution barriers are only logical in a culture built on consumption. Poetry, art, and critical thinking are luxury goods in a way. I have no problem understanding that for a lot of people these things are, or seem to be, completely irrelevant to the lives they lead.
It may be a bit far fetched, but somehow it is relevant: I saw an interview with the musician Blixa Bargeld recently. When asked why he had always been rebellious and challenging, he said he was genetically so disposed. I found that very funny. Nowadays it seems like everything is explained by genes, but you very rarely hear our genetic material used to explain eccentricities, opposition or originality. And he could be right, maybe the desire to oppose and to question is part of some human beings’ genetic material just like illnesses and hair colour? But even if this is the case, we are still part of a collective where we take on or are given different roles in relationship to others. In an individualistic culture like ours this aspect is often overlooked.
To make something public is always a suggestion for the general agenda as I see it. But if only a few are interested in what I believe is important, it is in a way not my problem. There are much more powerful economic and political interests that choose what is to be central or dominant. The fact is I never felt very in sync with my time or with my generation. It used to bother me, but it doesn’t anymore.
You can find excerpts from some of Lene Berg’s films here:
http://vimeopro.com/user18434138/leneberg
.
[This text was originally published in Fillip 19.]
In 2008, shortly after discovering her work, I wrote a text about Lene Berg for C Magazine entitled “Glad the CIA Is Immoral,” focusing on her project Gentlemen & Arseholes (2007) and how it spoke directly to so many of my ongoing concerns about art, how art may or may not become political. The text ended by going a bit over-the-top, with a last line that read: “Lene Berg is the artist I have been waiting for all of my life.”
In 2011, Lene and I collaborated on the project Big Brother Where Art Thou?, a work that took place entirely on Facebook and mixed reflections on George Orwell and his work with research into how the state security apparatus uses social media to monitor the lives of those who use it. Each day for one week we sat at our respective computers—Lene in Berlin, me in Montreal—and talked on Skype as we posted material on these themes in response to each other’s posts. The Brother Where Art Thou? Facebook page still exists, an archive of a moment in time before the recent NSA scandal broke, a period in which the possibility that governments might use Facebook to infiltrate the lives of its users still seemed more like vague Orwellian rumours than reality.
It is worth noting that Lene Berg often takes a historical footnote as the source material for her projects and employs her ensuing research to reveal paradoxes and gaps in how we see history and its relation to current predicaments, for example: how an anti-communist discourse promoting modernist artistic freedom laid the groundwork for our current, considerably less free cultural field. Her work suggests that consensus views of politics, history, sexuality, etc., are often misleading, that they reveal considerably more in what they exclude, in how they leave things out, than they are able to tell us about the machinations of the world or what happened in the past.
Our conversation took place over email.
—Jacob Wren
Jacob Wren: When I first discovered your work what struck me most was how concretely you addressed the relation between art and politics. I was wondering, since you address it quite often, if you have some general thoughts about how art and politics relate? And if your feelings around these questions changed at all in and around the Stalin by Picasso (2008) scandals, when your project examining a single 1953 drawing that Picasso made of Stalin – a project that consisted of a video, a series of drawings and three public banners – had the banners unexpectedly removed, I believe we can say censored, by the presenting institutions in both Oslo and in New York.
Lene Berg: There is no clear line between art and politics. But the relationship between the two is not static and it is not always easy to spot or to define. It is full of contradictions. It changes. It can also be very specific for certain situations, individuals, or institutions.
One of my starting points for the project Gentlemen & Arseholes was the feeling that I lived in a free world, but that, at the same time, there were very strict and definite limits to that freedom. The problem was, and is, that these limits are often so ingrained that they are not perceived as limits, but rather they are regarded as laws of nature. In the beginning of the project I was stunned by how manipulatively art and philosophy were used during the Cold War by the CIA and its allies. At the same time this confirmed that there is power in these fields. The beauty is that artistic power is different from political power, even if at certain times they can collide. Artistic power is about spreading ideas, and no one controls the impact of a film, a text, or an image completely—even when one funds them.
What happened with Stalin by Picasso confirmed just how contentious, in this sense how powerful, art can be, in many ways and on many levels, but the force of the reactions against it was much stronger than I could ever have imagined. The visual illiteracy of some of the criticism shocked me. Since then, I more and more have the feeling that we in the so-called West, or in the former West, live in a quite restricted and narrow cultural environment. What is discussed within an art context, in terms of what an image represents, for instance, has not reached a broader public and therefore has very little bearing outside of the art scene (for lack of a better word). Images printed in a newspaper or art shown in a public space are still to a high degree read as propaganda or illustrations. The public and the press can in general not deal with complexities or ambiguities. This is a democratic problem as it promotes stupidity, ignorance, and manipulation.
I find the definition of “political art” problematic. As I see it artworks that address political issues are not necessarily more political than other works, they often just look critical or political, like a style or a genre. A lot of left-wing art, for example, is merely reproducing ideas that are accepted and acclaimed in the social circles of the artists and curators distributing them. As they mainly illustrate established points of view the potential impact is minimal. I do not wish to illustrate my opinion in my work—on the contrary, I try to challenge and question my views. At the same time, there is of course a relationship between how I think and what I produce. There are no clear lines. And one has to remember that art and politics are on one level only words, two abstract categories that do not necessarily describe reality very accurately.
JW: There was the incredible irony that when Pablo Picasso first made the drawing of Joseph Stalin, it upset people because it was seen as tarnishing the image or memory of Stalin, but when you showed the exact same drawing in Oslo and New York people were upset because it was seen to praise him. These are both highly charged reactions. I wonder if a strong, immediate emotional reaction to an image might short circuit a more nuanced reading. If some of the same people who denounced your work might also be able to read images in a more complex way in other circumstances. Your work often heads directly for societal sore spots: political control of art, sex work, etc. You want to be in precarious territory, but once there you provide such a complex, nuanced perspective. How do you see this dynamic between emotionally charged material and a more critical view?
LB: As a matter of fact, I did not at all foresee that Stalin by Picasso would evoke such strong feelings, which in hindsight might seem naive. I thought some people would be provoked or annoyed by the fact that Picasso had made a portrait of Stalin and that this possibly would lead to discussions around art, independence, post-WWII battles, and maybe even about the myth of the lonely genius. But it turned out that Stalin was the problem, more than Picasso. And it was in fact not so much the image of Stalin that was a problem, even if that also created some of the anger, but his role in Western history. No one wanted that history back on the table. In other words I hit a sore spot, but not exactly the one I had aimed for.
But yes, I think you are right, very charged reactions are often a product of immediate emotional responses based on second-hand information. And one has of course very limited control over the reception of one’s own work, if at all. The interpretation is more often than not dependent on one or more middlemen or middlewomen—distributors, curators, critics, etc. When the general press/media is involved there is no way to control the presentation or the discussion. After all, news journalists tend to seek controversy, not meaning or content. The media-driven nature of the discussion somehow takes on a life of its own.
For instance, a stranger attacked me quite violently at a party once during the controversy around Stalin by Picasso. He accused me of being an egotistical artist trying to deliberately smear the labour party and hurt people to get PR for myself. He had only seen a photoshopped image in the paper and read the statement from the party secretary who took down the banners. Some time afterward he apologized through a common friend as he had realized that the project was much more and quite different from the impression he had gotten from the media.
So even if I am not afraid of controversy, and even like to deal with topics that potentially are controversial, I don’t really believe in simple provocation. It often has the consequence that people close themselves off and then nothing new can enter.
JW: It’s a striking moment, this hitting “a sore spot, but not exactly the one you had aimed for.” There’s always something electric when we hit the wrong targets, when the meaning of a given work gets away from the artist. Also something distressing.
Your film Kopfkino (2012) features eight women who work as dominatrix’s telling stories about their work, seated along a table reminiscent of the Last Super (perhaps also a twist on Judy Chicago’s The Dinner Party.) This is territory that could definitely offend a certain kind of person, maybe not someone in the art world, but certainly someone in the American religious right. In Kopfkino, I suspect the relation between art and politics is different than some of the other projects we’ve been discussing; that is, that it has more to do with giving these women an opportunity to speak. Was there anything the women in the film said that surprised you, or that was unexpected? From your perspective, what does it mean to have these women speaking for themselves about their work?
LB: The starting point for Kopfkino was actually questions more about storytelling and fiction than questions about sex workers or S&M. I got the idea after a dinner with one of the ladies where she told me about her work as a dominatrix. I was always interested in the function of stories, and how the structure of a story shapes the content and vice versa. Apart from being entertaining, stories are of course vehicles to spread ideas, knowledge, experience, and morality, as well as myths, lies, and propaganda. The stories Dunja Eckert-Jakobi told me that night were very concrete and very personal. Without having to force it, they automatically opened to so many charged and central themes, such as hierarchy, money, gender, social roles, and of course sex. I was also fascinated by the way she told her stories, how she described her clients and the situations, and how she built the narratives.
There is a lot of humour in the film, but some of the things the women talk about are so intricate and complex that most people have a hard time figuring them out. Such as the discussion about a pedophile client: Should one help him live out his fantasies in order to protect kids from him or will the staging of his fantasies actually make it easier for him to realize them afterward? This discussion is relevant for movie making as well as other artistic expressions. For instance, when you picture violent events, abuse, or discrimination, are you presenting a cathartic experience or are you in fact inspiring people to do the same, giving them visual examples of how it could be done as well as a structure, a story, that makes sense of such actions?
One of the themes in Kopfkino is the floating division between fiction and reality. Even if we believe we can separate the two, fiction and reality are intertwined in many ways and forms. One might say that fiction is reality as long as we believe in it. And as a culture Westerners live with a hard-to-handle cocktail: a fundamentally Christian morality on the one hand and on the other hand a capitalist ideology, which sooner or later accepts almost everything that is commercially successful even if it is morally suspect. Except maybe for prostitution, which is still illegal in most of the Western world. This fact was of course also important in the idea for Kopfkino and how to stage it. From the start I knew I wanted it to be about fiction; not fiction as the opposite of truth—on the contrary, fiction as a way of revealing something true, or perhaps rather something real. I wanted the women to speak as subjects and not as victims. I wanted to avoid stigmatization and pity. In a sense I wanted to normalize something that is regarded as bizarre and perverse. These women sell their time and their bodies, but most people do that in one way or another and I have a much bigger problem with intellectual prostitution than with what they do. Since they are dealing with things that sometimes are dangerous, sometimes disgusting, and often extremely demanding, they are forced to reflect upon their own responsibility and limits, including the role of money in their work. Does the fact that they are being paid mean that they have to deny their own pleasure? Is “a professional” not supposed to be fully present, just giving his or her services without using his or her own personality, judgment, or desire? Such questions are of course relevant far beyond the world of S&M.
JW: How do you think Kopfkino relates to feminism? In one sense, the women are empowered, have a lot of control over their lives and, within the film itself, on how their stories are told. But in another sense they are still employed by men. Do you think Kopfkino relates to feminism at all or is that a misleading way to watch the film?
LB: Even if I never try to illustrate my opinion or a specific theory in my work, I think Kopfkino fundamentally is a feminist film. But I have also met people who find it anti-feminist. It depends on how one defines feminism I suppose. And it is a tricky film to place within any category really. Some of the role-playing games described are very archaic and old-fashioned. Almost scarily so. You have to wonder how these often medieval hierarchies have survived through centuries, in the shape of sexual fantasies and desires. At the same time, the variety of female personalities, in spite of the clichés they are dressed up as, is impossible to overlook and adds other and unexpected dimensions to the picture.
I find it interesting that Kopfkino can be read in many different contexts and using different theories. The women’s stories are very rich and full of questions that are relevant to various discussions – about gender, sex, labour, power, and alienation, to mention a few. Then there is another level, which is about how they tell their stories and comment on each other’s experiences. And on another level there are questions about authenticity, staging, and reality, which lie in the way the film is shot and edited.
I personally find the mix of reality and fantasy in the stories themselves very intriguing. Since desire is one of the things one cannot fake, there is some sort of truth, or reality, to the role-playing games these women stage. There is also the aspect of shifting roles: that one individual has several possibilities to express herself or himself, including sexually. But one needs a stage, a setting to be able to go outside of one’s social role. S&M is one such scene. I also see several parallels between their profession and filmmaking. There is a certain degree of illusion and a lot of timing involved. These are hard to define skills, but they are central to human communication, to storytelling, and to acting.
What does it mean to play a role for money? Is it empowering to handle other people’s sexual desires or enslaving? I honestly don’t know, but I do not perceive these women as particularly oppressed. Some of them seem to be in possession of knowledge about their own sexuality and about sexual desire in general that I have seldom encountered in such a frank and non-idealized way. At the same time, I do think their work can be boring, degrading, and exhausting both for the mind and the body. Most of them also have other jobs or they study.
JW: I feel your work doesn’t play a game I often see in visual art: the artist keeping all the cards close to his or her chest, creating works that are unreadable without a certain amount of background information, often to be found in the catalogue or brochure. In your work, I often don’t need any other information apart from what I experience in the work itself. Do you agree with this assessment? How do you see this aspect of your practice? (Perhaps it also makes your work more difficult to write about because so much of what needs to be said has already been conveyed.) Might this directness also have something to do with your background in film?
LB: It is true that I like my works to be sort of self-contained, so that they can be seen without knowing the background discussion or my references. I try to avoid talking in codes or mystifying things, but my projects are often composed by contradictions and paradoxes, which may also make them hard to write about. When I start to work on an idea I often focus on the surface, what it will look and feel like. As the project develops this may change, but I like there to be a certain dynamic between the surface and the content, so that as one goes into the work ones perception of the surface will be altered and sometimes even completely changed in the process.
It is very likely that my background in film has shaped my way of working. Movies are in general expected to communicate immediately with everyone. This need tends to turn any content into the same kind of story or message, which is something I am trying to avoid at almost any cost. My method is probably most of all a result of the years I worked with the film company Hinden in Stockholm. We were a handful people working together on very different kinds of projects, from advertising to feature films, short films, art projects, etc. Sometimes I was directing, often not. Parallel to the practical work, which at times was quite hard and demanding, we discussed a lot of theoretical issues in relationship to what we were doing and producing. Without this mix of physical and practical work and the continuous discussions around it, I probably would have been a different person and artist.
JW: I’m still thinking about something you said earlier, about how we live “in a free world, but that, at the same time, there are very strict and definite limits to that freedom.” And how, over the past ten or so years, maybe since 9/11, my feelings around our apparent (Western) freedom have changed so much. How more and more it seems we’re no longer free to gather and protest, or how our confidence that we have privacy—for example, online or in an email—has lessened. And that the celebration of (illusory) Western freedom might have had more to do with the Cold War—with convincing the world that “democracy” was better than “communism”—than it did with any actual desire for, for example, free speech. (But then I think about McCarthyism, how little room for dissent there was during that period, and wonder if my sense of history is simply off.) Has your thinking around different kinds of freedom changed at all over the last ten or fifteen years? Do you think there’s been a significant recent shift?
LB: I had this feeling long before 9/11, but since then it has become more evident and tangible. Living off and on in New York has made it clear to me that a corporate worldview is more and more dominating. While politicians speak of pluralism and freedom, the preferred lifestyle is quite narrow and has very little tolerance for difference. Actually it is less tolerant or open now than in the 80’s when I was a teenager, which is quite surprising to me.
Sadly, what is going on now is not so different from the era of McCarthyism or pre-WWII: the law is used to suppress difference of opinion and to defend people of privilege. I suppose 9/11 made it easier to change the laws in this direction. The law is the key to rule the world, at least if you have the police and the courts to back it up, and the big corporations are better protected by the law than the individual at this point.
The West has so many blind spots in terms of what freedom actually means, or can mean, and very little consciousness about the actual conditions for freedom, or for democracy or pluralism for that matter. It seems to me that a lot of the challenges that were present at the beginning and middle of the last century are still with us. More and more often I experience how racist, sexist and nationalistic views are used as part of a social struggle as less privileged groups and individuals turn to white-supremacy, infantile nationalism or anti-gay ideas to oppose the liberal bourgeoisie, to use an old fashioned term.
JW: I now think my last question was too naive. (Though, at the same time, I’m always searching for ways to produce productive naiveté.) Something may have shifted with 9/11, but the history of Western unfreedom is such a long one. I’ve read a great deal of history, but often think not exactly that I don’t know history well enough (of course I don’t), but that I don’t feel history enough. And I did clearly feel the restrictions directly following 9/11, perhaps suggesting it’s not such an important even in generalized Western unfreedom, but was an important event within my own personal sense of it. (Much like Vietnam was a significant event for a previous generation.) With earlier works like The Weimar Conspiracy (2007) and The Drowned One (2008) you question how things enter history and what we actually know about them (versus what we think we know). Do you know how your interest in the paradoxes of writing and experiencing history first began? Can history be more or less objective? More recent projects seem to have moved away from the topic.
LB: This may sound strange, but for me history was never really my topic. I happened to discover some historical events that presented the possibility to deal with things that preoccupied me. As history is used to motivate present actions and ideas, turning and tossing historic events is a way to question the present perception and representation of things. Even if only indirectly.
I am interested in storytelling and the relationship between stories and the realities they depict. History is in a way our common story; it is used to shed light on the present. There are of course many ways to construct and tell stories, and depending on how they are told they will mean very different things and sometimes have very different consequences. That also goes for history.
Also, for some years I had problems funding my work, and I discovered that I could use found footage, archival material, collages, etc., to produce quite complex things for very little cash. It gave me a certain freedom for a while, and I will probably do projects like that again, but I needed to move on. Or actually: to move back to where I came from. I like teamwork, working with actors, sets, etc. That is what I started out doing and it has been a great pleasure to be able to return to that.
Even if my projects look different and seem to deal with very different topics, some themes run through them all. I don’t try to pin these themes down though—they are simply part of my thinking and doing however I work, for good and for bad. I like every project to have its own challenges, even its own style and expression. For me an idea for a new project is more about knowing how to work on it and how to define the elements out of which the final project will be constructed than knowing exactly what it will look like in the end.
JW: The kinds of contradictions and paradoxes in your work usually aren’t formal aspects of the work itself, aren’t contradictions you create. More often they are contradictions and paradoxes you discover in the world and then focus our attention on. In this sense your work needs to be as clear as possible in order to present the full complexity of nuance and questioning that real-life paradoxes generate. How do you see the dynamic in your work between clarity and paradox? Do you know why you’re attracted to these kinds of narratives?
LB: I seek clarity as much as possible, that is true. But I distrust one liners and beloved simplifications, or clichés, if you like. There are many mysteries in human relations and conditions, and things that are made up of contradictions and paradoxes seem real to me. Also they protect me from confirming the obvious and from reproducing automatic thinking.
The following may sound a bit pretentious but I believe the human mind is incapable of grasping the truth as it is. Not only because the truth is often cruel, but because our minds are not conditioned for it. I do believe there are facts that are beyond fiction, but they are very few and to understand them we need a system, a fiction, if you like. I believe fiction, in a broad sense of the word, is a human way of making sense. Fiction is not necessarily about lies, but neither is it about truth in an absolute sense. The question is not so much whether something is fiction or fact, but what kind of fiction it is and with what purpose it is being told, reproduced and repeated. I am interested not in disclosing another fact that can be added to the general story but in presenting my material in a form that adds something and possibly also questions a dominating fiction. Such as the macho myth around Picasso or the notion that there is no ideology in the present liberal democracies, just to mention two very general examples.
That said, I have to add that language is not of great help when I try to pin down these ideas. The words and notions used to define things like fact and fiction easily create some sort of mental labyrinth when you start to challenge them. Sometimes I enjoy being in such labyrinths, at least for a while. With a bit of experience I have learned how to get out of them, otherwise I would have gone mad a long time ago.
JW: Language can certainly complicate or obscure as easily as clarify. Tools for communication can easily flip over into defense mechanisms. But, for me, there are so many aspects of your projects that cut through art, that speak so clearly and directly to the world. Would you like this work to be less marginal?
LB: I think some of my projects relate to very small circles, such as Gentlemen & Arseholes and Dirty Young Loose (2013) whereas others, like Stalin by Picasso or Kopfkino, are projects with a much broader potential. I do not think that it is important that everything reaches everyone, but I do think the current distribution systems are limited by old-fashioned categories: a lot of things can’t reach an audience because they don’t fit established genres or boxes. At the same time, such distribution barriers are only logical in a culture built on consumption. Poetry, art, and critical thinking are luxury goods in a way. I have no problem understanding that for a lot of people these things are, or seem to be, completely irrelevant to the lives they lead.
It may be a bit far fetched, but somehow it is relevant: I saw an interview with the musician Blixa Bargeld recently. When asked why he had always been rebellious and challenging, he said he was genetically so disposed. I found that very funny. Nowadays it seems like everything is explained by genes, but you very rarely hear our genetic material used to explain eccentricities, opposition or originality. And he could be right, maybe the desire to oppose and to question is part of some human beings’ genetic material just like illnesses and hair colour? But even if this is the case, we are still part of a collective where we take on or are given different roles in relationship to others. In an individualistic culture like ours this aspect is often overlooked.
To make something public is always a suggestion for the general agenda as I see it. But if only a few are interested in what I believe is important, it is in a way not my problem. There are much more powerful economic and political interests that choose what is to be central or dominant. The fact is I never felt very in sync with my time or with my generation. It used to bother me, but it doesn’t anymore.
You can find excerpts from some of Lene Berg’s films here:
http://vimeopro.com/user18434138/leneberg
.
Labels:
An essay by Jacob Wren,
Lene Berg
December 28, 2015
A long and short playlist for 2015 (with commentary)
I said I wasn't going to do this anymore, because YouTube now has too many commercials, but it seems I can't stop.
I've now made YouTube playlists in 2010, 2011, Japan, 2013, 2014 and now 2015 (also above.)
The playlist for 2015 is so long (over five hundred videos) that this year I've also made a shorter one that contains some of my favourites.
In previous years, my commentary was about how things I do on the internet now seem part of, or even more interesting, than the rest of my artistic practice. But this year all I'm thinking about is my internet addiction. For the first time in my life I'm finding it difficult to read and I think it might partly have too do with how much time I spend online.
I have just managed to spend two weekends offline, and will try to keep spending weekends away from this thing for the rest of the year. I don't particularly think I'll succeed. But we'll see what happens.
I think what disturbs me most is how little interest I have in doing anything else.
.
Labels:
Jacob Wren YouTube Playlists
December 21, 2015
Internet Addiction
.
I have decided to try to stay off the internet during the weekends. (I just managed my first weekend in more or less ever.) I will most likely fail, but I thought I would announce it here anyway. Each time I fall off the wagon I will do my best to get back on. When it comes to email, ‘it can wait until Monday’ will hopefully become my new mantra. So if you see me on social media during the weekend you will know that I am weak.
.
I have decided to try to stay off the internet during the weekends. (I just managed my first weekend in more or less ever.) I will most likely fail, but I thought I would announce it here anyway. Each time I fall off the wagon I will do my best to get back on. When it comes to email, ‘it can wait until Monday’ will hopefully become my new mantra. So if you see me on social media during the weekend you will know that I am weak.
.
December 18, 2015
December 14, 2015
Rashayla Marie Brown: "Especially to the radiant child and the wunderkind, I ask you to open your hands and release your anxiety."
.
I’m not going to lie to you. There are rewards for this amnesia – people will call you avant-garde or controversial, you don’t seem hindered by oppression, you aren’t didactic, you will gain access into places – alone – because you are one of the chosen ones who don’t challenge the institution. But you will be in the ivory tower, alone.
We can explore such ideas as the post-black, the post-racial, and the post-feminist because our ancestors’ world was a world of firsts before the post. I appeal to you to acknowledge your influences, publicly and loudly. I implore you to do your research and cite your sources. I ask you to share. Do not be lulled by the open gate or window, and then close it behind you so no one else like you can enter. A sense of competition is bred into the art world that makes you feel like you will lose if you aren’t the chosen one. Especially to the radiant child and the wunderkind, I ask you to open your hands and release your anxiety.
- Rashayla Marie Brown, Open Letter To My Fellow Young Artists And Scholars Who Work On The Margins – A Tribute to Terry Adkins
[Read the rest of the essay here.]
.
I’m not going to lie to you. There are rewards for this amnesia – people will call you avant-garde or controversial, you don’t seem hindered by oppression, you aren’t didactic, you will gain access into places – alone – because you are one of the chosen ones who don’t challenge the institution. But you will be in the ivory tower, alone.
We can explore such ideas as the post-black, the post-racial, and the post-feminist because our ancestors’ world was a world of firsts before the post. I appeal to you to acknowledge your influences, publicly and loudly. I implore you to do your research and cite your sources. I ask you to share. Do not be lulled by the open gate or window, and then close it behind you so no one else like you can enter. A sense of competition is bred into the art world that makes you feel like you will lose if you aren’t the chosen one. Especially to the radiant child and the wunderkind, I ask you to open your hands and release your anxiety.
- Rashayla Marie Brown, Open Letter To My Fellow Young Artists And Scholars Who Work On The Margins – A Tribute to Terry Adkins
[Read the rest of the essay here.]
.
Labels:
Quotes,
Rashayla Marie Brown,
Terry Adkins
December 13, 2015
Karissa Chen: "It’s simply that you cannot imagine you could be wrong, and so you cannot see."
.
The thing I want to tell that male journalist with the Asian wife, or even to Michael Derrick Hudson with his stolen name, is that these Asian women whom you’ve reduced to names and monikers and symbols of your discontent — they fall outside of your imaginations. Despite all of your privilege, your belief that you have the right to imagine and shape worlds as you see fit, you lack the capacity to conceive of the multitudes that lie inside the women whom you claim to speak for. Your singular wife. Yi-Fen Chou. My grandmother. Myself. And so many other Asian women I know. We are constantly breaking stereotypes. We have varying, changing dreams, and move through this world expressing ourselves in unexpected ways. We are living, breathing examples of how your constructions of us are paper-thin, weightless. It’s simply that you cannot imagine you could be wrong, and so you cannot see.
One more point on audacity. I don’t think all audacity looks the same. The audacity that a white man has because he believes he is entitled to something very particular, something very expected is different from the audacity of an immigrant who has no idea what is coming, who plunges ahead despite not knowing, but who, despite all odds, believes she deserves something better, something greater than her imagination. This is the same audacity that will allow her to let go of everything she’s worked for if it comes to it, because she has the audacity to reimagine her future, again and again, as is necessary. She has the audacity to expect better even when the world tells her she shouldn’t dare.
- Karissa Chen, The Audacity to Dream: On Asian Women, Feminism, and My Grandmother
[Read the rest of the essay here.]
.
The thing I want to tell that male journalist with the Asian wife, or even to Michael Derrick Hudson with his stolen name, is that these Asian women whom you’ve reduced to names and monikers and symbols of your discontent — they fall outside of your imaginations. Despite all of your privilege, your belief that you have the right to imagine and shape worlds as you see fit, you lack the capacity to conceive of the multitudes that lie inside the women whom you claim to speak for. Your singular wife. Yi-Fen Chou. My grandmother. Myself. And so many other Asian women I know. We are constantly breaking stereotypes. We have varying, changing dreams, and move through this world expressing ourselves in unexpected ways. We are living, breathing examples of how your constructions of us are paper-thin, weightless. It’s simply that you cannot imagine you could be wrong, and so you cannot see.
*
One more point on audacity. I don’t think all audacity looks the same. The audacity that a white man has because he believes he is entitled to something very particular, something very expected is different from the audacity of an immigrant who has no idea what is coming, who plunges ahead despite not knowing, but who, despite all odds, believes she deserves something better, something greater than her imagination. This is the same audacity that will allow her to let go of everything she’s worked for if it comes to it, because she has the audacity to reimagine her future, again and again, as is necessary. She has the audacity to expect better even when the world tells her she shouldn’t dare.
- Karissa Chen, The Audacity to Dream: On Asian Women, Feminism, and My Grandmother
[Read the rest of the essay here.]
.
Labels:
Karissa Chen,
Quotes
December 12, 2015
December 11, 2015
Zoe S.C. Todd Quote
.
e) Listen to people without MFAs or PhDs. Listen to people who have lived experience. Listen to people who are angry. Listen to people who are not being shown at galleries. Don’t tell us to be polite. Don’t police our voices. Just sit with it. Ask yourself why people are angry. Acknowledge any part you play in that.
f) If you have the urge to be a White Saviour and speak for us, just stop. Just turn off your laptop, back away from your desk and go make yourself useful by working in reciprocity with Indigenous people and/or POC. Ask yourself how you can amplify the work of POC and/or Indigenous people without centring Colonial institutions or legal orders or colonial voices.
- Zoe S.C. Todd, So long and thanks
[Read the rest of the essay here.]
.
e) Listen to people without MFAs or PhDs. Listen to people who have lived experience. Listen to people who are angry. Listen to people who are not being shown at galleries. Don’t tell us to be polite. Don’t police our voices. Just sit with it. Ask yourself why people are angry. Acknowledge any part you play in that.
f) If you have the urge to be a White Saviour and speak for us, just stop. Just turn off your laptop, back away from your desk and go make yourself useful by working in reciprocity with Indigenous people and/or POC. Ask yourself how you can amplify the work of POC and/or Indigenous people without centring Colonial institutions or legal orders or colonial voices.
- Zoe S.C. Todd, So long and thanks
[Read the rest of the essay here.]
.
Labels:
Quotes,
Zoe S.C. Todd
December 9, 2015
Jesse B. Staniforth on “of the North” – Quebec filmmaker uses YouTube and unauthorized music to portray the Inuit
.
I highly recommend this piece by Jesse B. Staniforth:
“of the North” – Quebec filmmaker uses YouTube and unauthorized music to portray the Inuit
As well, in a Facebook comment Jesse added this note:
The story I submitted was so much longer than it was supposed to be so a lot of it had to be cut for space (and they did a GREAT job). However, I originally ended with this coda, which I think is worth sharing:
I emailed Mara Gourd-Mercado for clarification about the statement, asking, “rather than presume the Indigenous audience of this film is misreading it, are you concerned that your reading of the film ‘confronting stereotypes’ is grounded in your lack of knowledge and experience of Indigenous communities? Do you stand by your contention that this film is critical of those stereotypes?”
Gourd-Mercado replied, “One of the main things we take away from our conversation last week and that is important for us to express right now is not the RIDM's perception of the film. We need to listen to the opinions that are emerging from the Inuit communities, and to establish communication channels with members of this community. We hope to be able to enter a more inclusive dialogue regarding the film and our programming moving forward. As we stated this takes time and we are ready to put in the work at any cost.”
.
I highly recommend this piece by Jesse B. Staniforth:
“of the North” – Quebec filmmaker uses YouTube and unauthorized music to portray the Inuit
As well, in a Facebook comment Jesse added this note:
The story I submitted was so much longer than it was supposed to be so a lot of it had to be cut for space (and they did a GREAT job). However, I originally ended with this coda, which I think is worth sharing:
I emailed Mara Gourd-Mercado for clarification about the statement, asking, “rather than presume the Indigenous audience of this film is misreading it, are you concerned that your reading of the film ‘confronting stereotypes’ is grounded in your lack of knowledge and experience of Indigenous communities? Do you stand by your contention that this film is critical of those stereotypes?”
Gourd-Mercado replied, “One of the main things we take away from our conversation last week and that is important for us to express right now is not the RIDM's perception of the film. We need to listen to the opinions that are emerging from the Inuit communities, and to establish communication channels with members of this community. We hope to be able to enter a more inclusive dialogue regarding the film and our programming moving forward. As we stated this takes time and we are ready to put in the work at any cost.”
.
Labels:
Jesse B. Staniforth,
of the North
December 8, 2015
Some favourite things from my 2015
.
(It seems I really do love lists. As is often the case with me, many of these things were released prior to 2015. I have listed them more or less in the order they gradually came to me.)
Books:
Bodymap – Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha
In an I – Popahna Brandes
May ’68 and Its Afterlives – Kristen Ross
Sister Outsider – Audre Lorde
Lee Lozano: Dropout Piece – Sarah Lehrer-Graiwer
The Fourth World – Diamela Eltit
Bodies of Work: Essays – Kathy Acker
Tattooed Forever – Dalia Rosetti (story in Animal Shelter 3)
Her 37th Year, An Index – Suzanne Scanlon
Garments Against Women – Anne Boyer
Writing:
Anything and everything by Hannah Black
Anything and everything by Jackie Wang
Music:
Aina More – For People With Short Attention Spans
Rapsody – Beauty & The Beast
Lexii Alijai – feel-less
Shamir – Rachet
Little Simz – A Curious Tale of Trials + Persons
Vince Staples - Summertime ‘06
THEESatisfaction – EarthEE
John Carter – Fields
Kelela – CUT 4 ME
Exhibitions:
Cuts Make The Country Better – Edith Brunette and François Lemieux
Talk Show – el instituto / SBC Gallery
Performances:
its not a thing – keyon gaskin
Resistance Solo – Miguel Pereira
Uro – Anna Natt
J'AURAIS AIMÉ TRAVERSER – Elaine Juteau in collaboration with Andrée-Anne Giguère and Luis Felipe Ortega Gil
.
(It seems I really do love lists. As is often the case with me, many of these things were released prior to 2015. I have listed them more or less in the order they gradually came to me.)
Books:
Bodymap – Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha
In an I – Popahna Brandes
May ’68 and Its Afterlives – Kristen Ross
Sister Outsider – Audre Lorde
Lee Lozano: Dropout Piece – Sarah Lehrer-Graiwer
The Fourth World – Diamela Eltit
Bodies of Work: Essays – Kathy Acker
Tattooed Forever – Dalia Rosetti (story in Animal Shelter 3)
Her 37th Year, An Index – Suzanne Scanlon
Garments Against Women – Anne Boyer
Writing:
Anything and everything by Hannah Black
Anything and everything by Jackie Wang
Music:
Aina More – For People With Short Attention Spans
Rapsody – Beauty & The Beast
Lexii Alijai – feel-less
Shamir – Rachet
Little Simz – A Curious Tale of Trials + Persons
Vince Staples - Summertime ‘06
THEESatisfaction – EarthEE
John Carter – Fields
Kelela – CUT 4 ME
Exhibitions:
Cuts Make The Country Better – Edith Brunette and François Lemieux
Talk Show – el instituto / SBC Gallery
Performances:
its not a thing – keyon gaskin
Resistance Solo – Miguel Pereira
Uro – Anna Natt
J'AURAIS AIMÉ TRAVERSER – Elaine Juteau in collaboration with Andrée-Anne Giguère and Luis Felipe Ortega Gil
.
December 6, 2015
Raymond Boisjoly tweet
.
Still thinking about this tweet from Raymond Boisjoly: "...as if art was more important than our responsibility to one another"
.
Still thinking about this tweet from Raymond Boisjoly: "...as if art was more important than our responsibility to one another"
.
Labels:
Raymond Boisjoly
December 3, 2015
November 30, 2015
Tania Canas Quote
.
We are not a resource to feed into your next artistic project. You may be talented at your particular craft but do not assume that this automatically translates to an ethical, responsible and self-determining process. Understand community cultural development methodology but also understand that it is not a full-proof methodology. Who and what institutions are benefiting from the exchange?
- Tania Canas, from Some points to consider if you’re an artist who wants to make work about refugees
[You can read the rest of the essay here.]
.
We are not a resource to feed into your next artistic project. You may be talented at your particular craft but do not assume that this automatically translates to an ethical, responsible and self-determining process. Understand community cultural development methodology but also understand that it is not a full-proof methodology. Who and what institutions are benefiting from the exchange?
- Tania Canas, from Some points to consider if you’re an artist who wants to make work about refugees
[You can read the rest of the essay here.]
.
Labels:
Tania Canas
November 29, 2015
Patricia Boushel Facebook post concerning of the North
.
"Many of us watched the of the North controversy billow up over the course of the past week. It’s fascinating to witness something that so few people saw gain such traction, but it’s also heartening that the reaction was so strong. Though social media is a terrifying identity construction machine through which we pick and choose the values by which we wish to be known by others and an arguably imbalanced tool for popular education, it’s an easy outlet for denouncing and condemning racism. Many wish for there to be a greater share of consideration, understanding and love towards those who’ve been especially disadvantaged, dispossessed and whose well-being is still not the bottom line of our own free will. I tried to watch the film, but by the time I got around to it, the circulated link was removed. We've heard from articulate folks that it is cruel, and I've heard from very wise and loving people that it was also beautiful. I vacillate between desire to have accessed the coveted object of discussion and the discomfort of yet again being in a position of witnessing a stilted perspective enabled by a tool for self-broadcast and public institutions that intend on increasing diversity content, and crafted by a singular privileged viewpoint. Rationally, the film being seen by more people could create a better context for conversation about its controversial content, and yet intuitively, the film being seen by more people will invariably wound the people in it, as well as so many others who identify with them. This isn’t about censorship against free speech, political correctness against artistry. The time of distanced, self-profiting voyeuristic cultural practices, particularly in our post-Truth and Reconciliation nation(s) is over. And how about making humility as valuable as creativity?
- Patricia Boushel
.
"Many of us watched the of the North controversy billow up over the course of the past week. It’s fascinating to witness something that so few people saw gain such traction, but it’s also heartening that the reaction was so strong. Though social media is a terrifying identity construction machine through which we pick and choose the values by which we wish to be known by others and an arguably imbalanced tool for popular education, it’s an easy outlet for denouncing and condemning racism. Many wish for there to be a greater share of consideration, understanding and love towards those who’ve been especially disadvantaged, dispossessed and whose well-being is still not the bottom line of our own free will. I tried to watch the film, but by the time I got around to it, the circulated link was removed. We've heard from articulate folks that it is cruel, and I've heard from very wise and loving people that it was also beautiful. I vacillate between desire to have accessed the coveted object of discussion and the discomfort of yet again being in a position of witnessing a stilted perspective enabled by a tool for self-broadcast and public institutions that intend on increasing diversity content, and crafted by a singular privileged viewpoint. Rationally, the film being seen by more people could create a better context for conversation about its controversial content, and yet intuitively, the film being seen by more people will invariably wound the people in it, as well as so many others who identify with them. This isn’t about censorship against free speech, political correctness against artistry. The time of distanced, self-profiting voyeuristic cultural practices, particularly in our post-Truth and Reconciliation nation(s) is over. And how about making humility as valuable as creativity?
- Patricia Boushel
.
Labels:
of the North,
Patricia Boushel
When people hear the word racist...
.
When people hear the word racist their first impulse is to become defensive, to say that they're not racist, etc. But we were all raised in a racist and sexist culture and we all have racism inside of us. It only gets worse if you disavow it.
.
When people hear the word racist their first impulse is to become defensive, to say that they're not racist, etc. But we were all raised in a racist and sexist culture and we all have racism inside of us. It only gets worse if you disavow it.
.
Labels:
of the North
November 27, 2015
In the interview...
.
In the interview he says "it's not a racist film." But for me this isn't possible. If we are both reasonable people, and you think the film is not racist, and I think that it is, than for you the film is not racist and for me it is. We have different histories, different experiences, and different ways of understanding these issues and questions. It is a debate. It cannot suddenly, objectively become one or the other. The fact that people are protesting the film opens the question and keeps it open. The next question is where do we go from there. And whose opinion gets to dominate the conversation. And is there any possibility that the discussion might actually lead somewhere productive, towards more justice and less racism in the world. All these questions are further complicated by our overwhelming - historical and current - situation of structural inequality.
.
In the interview he says "it's not a racist film." But for me this isn't possible. If we are both reasonable people, and you think the film is not racist, and I think that it is, than for you the film is not racist and for me it is. We have different histories, different experiences, and different ways of understanding these issues and questions. It is a debate. It cannot suddenly, objectively become one or the other. The fact that people are protesting the film opens the question and keeps it open. The next question is where do we go from there. And whose opinion gets to dominate the conversation. And is there any possibility that the discussion might actually lead somewhere productive, towards more justice and less racism in the world. All these questions are further complicated by our overwhelming - historical and current - situation of structural inequality.
.
Labels:
of the North
November 25, 2015
Art and Politics
.
Every time I have an argument about art and politics it strikes me anew: how weak I am at engaging with people I disagree with. And how little experience I actually have with the task.
.
Every time I have an argument about art and politics it strikes me anew: how weak I am at engaging with people I disagree with. And how little experience I actually have with the task.
.
November 24, 2015
Nostalgia
.
Reading Carl Wilson on Adele started to make me incredibly nostalgic for a time "when self-consciously cool people put populist music down on principle." (But if I think about it more, I feel what we need isn't a return to cool elitism but rather more praise and attention for work that is in continuity and dialog with the rage of Black Lives Matter, Idle No More, The Mongrel Coalition Against Gringpo, current feminist waves, etc.)
.
Reading Carl Wilson on Adele started to make me incredibly nostalgic for a time "when self-consciously cool people put populist music down on principle." (But if I think about it more, I feel what we need isn't a return to cool elitism but rather more praise and attention for work that is in continuity and dialog with the rage of Black Lives Matter, Idle No More, The Mongrel Coalition Against Gringpo, current feminist waves, etc.)
.
November 19, 2015
I've started saying I'm semi-retired
.
"Beware the barrenness of a busy life." - Socrates
I've started saying I'm semi-retired. It's both a light joke and deadly serious, as if my life depended on it. So far, in what we might call reality, I'm working more or less as much as I ever have. But my attitude towards this work is hopefully, gradually starting to change. Saying I'm semi-retired is a critique of the fact that, as an artist, I feel I'm under constant pressure to over-produce. As soon as I finish one project I'm already being asked what the next project is. It seems there is a natural, unspoken assumption that what an artist does is produce a never-ending supply of works that fulfill an equally never-ending series of empty slots within various institutions, projects and structures.
I'm naturally somewhat prolific, so overproduction has never seemed like an impossible task. But I've also felt that, for me, being artistically prolific is almost like a bad habit. I think the absolutely hardest thing to do as an artist is to keep making good work, work with integrity, over an entire lifetime. (I have now been making work for twenty-five years which is perhaps why these questions are now hitting me with such peculiar force.) I've always thought that the best way to last is to produce less, to really consider each step and never unnecessarily rush into anything. At the same time, at certain moments, a sense of recklessness and spontaneity is also essential. It's not like I've got it all figured out. And I don't exactly want to figure it out. I want to remain open enough to whatever happens that I might still end up somewhere I previously didn't even have the tools to consider possible.
Nonetheless, I've started saying I'm semi-retired. It has something to do with no longer feeling I have to do everything, feeling some things are more important than others and my actions have to reflect such values and realities. One definition of capitalism is an insatiable need for growth, for more, always more, and I feel as an artist, often living hand to mouth, I am also expected to do both as much as possible and often more than I can. I am searching for ways to say, more clearly than I have before, that this is not where it's at. Time needs to be understood in other ways. We'll still have to see in the future whether saying I'm semi-retired is only wishful thinking or, to put it more bluntly, to what degree I end up a hypocrite. But more is certainly not always more.
Finally, as a critique of many of the assumptions in what I've just written, I will finish with - and very much hope you will read - this piece by Pampi Thirdeyefell: Art with Teeth because #CreativesLabor
.
"Beware the barrenness of a busy life." - Socrates
I've started saying I'm semi-retired. It's both a light joke and deadly serious, as if my life depended on it. So far, in what we might call reality, I'm working more or less as much as I ever have. But my attitude towards this work is hopefully, gradually starting to change. Saying I'm semi-retired is a critique of the fact that, as an artist, I feel I'm under constant pressure to over-produce. As soon as I finish one project I'm already being asked what the next project is. It seems there is a natural, unspoken assumption that what an artist does is produce a never-ending supply of works that fulfill an equally never-ending series of empty slots within various institutions, projects and structures.
I'm naturally somewhat prolific, so overproduction has never seemed like an impossible task. But I've also felt that, for me, being artistically prolific is almost like a bad habit. I think the absolutely hardest thing to do as an artist is to keep making good work, work with integrity, over an entire lifetime. (I have now been making work for twenty-five years which is perhaps why these questions are now hitting me with such peculiar force.) I've always thought that the best way to last is to produce less, to really consider each step and never unnecessarily rush into anything. At the same time, at certain moments, a sense of recklessness and spontaneity is also essential. It's not like I've got it all figured out. And I don't exactly want to figure it out. I want to remain open enough to whatever happens that I might still end up somewhere I previously didn't even have the tools to consider possible.
Nonetheless, I've started saying I'm semi-retired. It has something to do with no longer feeling I have to do everything, feeling some things are more important than others and my actions have to reflect such values and realities. One definition of capitalism is an insatiable need for growth, for more, always more, and I feel as an artist, often living hand to mouth, I am also expected to do both as much as possible and often more than I can. I am searching for ways to say, more clearly than I have before, that this is not where it's at. Time needs to be understood in other ways. We'll still have to see in the future whether saying I'm semi-retired is only wishful thinking or, to put it more bluntly, to what degree I end up a hypocrite. But more is certainly not always more.
Finally, as a critique of many of the assumptions in what I've just written, I will finish with - and very much hope you will read - this piece by Pampi Thirdeyefell: Art with Teeth because #CreativesLabor
.
November 17, 2015
Dream
.
Last night I dreamt I was an arsonist. As I headed to set one last fire, I got a text saying "it's a trap," turned around, and decided to go see art instead.
.
Last night I dreamt I was an arsonist. As I headed to set one last fire, I got a text saying "it's a trap," turned around, and decided to go see art instead.
.
October 15, 2015
Fred Moten Quote
.
with nothing it’s impossible and easier, the same but really close to one another but unbridgeably far from one another, the way we flee a broken park when the island is a shipwreck and a language lab and half of school falls away.
- Fred Moten, The Feel Trio
.
with nothing it’s impossible and easier, the same but really close to one another but unbridgeably far from one another, the way we flee a broken park when the island is a shipwreck and a language lab and half of school falls away.
- Fred Moten, The Feel Trio
.
Labels:
Fred Moten,
Quotes
The mid-career blues...
.
Of course, in a way, I meant that I have something like the mid-career blues: a feeling that I've done a lot already and it's not as clear as it was before what else I should do, how or why. If I can actually do anything better than I've done before and what attitude I might take, or what kinds of changes I might make, to make it so. But I also had the thought that 'the mid-career blues' are something that exists, something that's going around: that many people who have been making art for a good while, who most likely have as much behind them as they perhaps have ahead, might feel something a bit like this. That it might be normal, and even that it is perfectly understandable.
.
Of course, in a way, I meant that I have something like the mid-career blues: a feeling that I've done a lot already and it's not as clear as it was before what else I should do, how or why. If I can actually do anything better than I've done before and what attitude I might take, or what kinds of changes I might make, to make it so. But I also had the thought that 'the mid-career blues' are something that exists, something that's going around: that many people who have been making art for a good while, who most likely have as much behind them as they perhaps have ahead, might feel something a bit like this. That it might be normal, and even that it is perfectly understandable.
.
October 14, 2015
letters we wrote to friends after reading "polyamorous love song"
.
Jasna Zmak in Croatia has started this beautiful thing:
letters we wrote to friends after reading "polyamorous love song"
An excerpt:
"It was then when I decided this was something I ought to do. So, I am giving this book to you, as a present. I am giving it to you, but on one condition. Or actually two. The first one is that you read it. The second is that, upon reading it, you do the same as I did: you think of a friend who you think might like it, who you think will be a nice addition to our small community, you give it to him/her as a present and along with it, write a letter to explain why you think this person and this book might go so well along. Then you give them the letter and the book, and you forward the letter to me, so I could publish it here.
You decide on the length of the letter, I am just asking for the language to be English so that more people could understand it… and, of course, at the end of the letter you make a small note about this principle so that when your friend is done with reading, he or she can send it to the next person, including a personalized letter, so that this circle could go on expanding…"
.
Jasna Zmak in Croatia has started this beautiful thing:
letters we wrote to friends after reading "polyamorous love song"
An excerpt:
"It was then when I decided this was something I ought to do. So, I am giving this book to you, as a present. I am giving it to you, but on one condition. Or actually two. The first one is that you read it. The second is that, upon reading it, you do the same as I did: you think of a friend who you think might like it, who you think will be a nice addition to our small community, you give it to him/her as a present and along with it, write a letter to explain why you think this person and this book might go so well along. Then you give them the letter and the book, and you forward the letter to me, so I could publish it here.
You decide on the length of the letter, I am just asking for the language to be English so that more people could understand it… and, of course, at the end of the letter you make a small note about this principle so that when your friend is done with reading, he or she can send it to the next person, including a personalized letter, so that this circle could go on expanding…"
.
Labels:
Jacob Wren,
Jasna Zmak,
Polyamorous Love Song
October 5, 2015
The DJ Who Gave Too Much Information in Europe
.
Coming soon:
The DJ Who Gave Too Much Information in:
Birmingham (Fierce Festival, Oct 10-11)
Manchester (Contact Theatre, Oct 14-15)
Bordeaux (Festival Novart, Oct 17-18)
Munich (Spielart/Pathos, Oct 31)
Cardiff (Experimentica, Nov 4-5)
Bonus: A letter about The DJ Who Gave Too Much Information
.
Coming soon:
The DJ Who Gave Too Much Information in:
Birmingham (Fierce Festival, Oct 10-11)
Manchester (Contact Theatre, Oct 14-15)
Bordeaux (Festival Novart, Oct 17-18)
Munich (Spielart/Pathos, Oct 31)
Cardiff (Experimentica, Nov 4-5)
Bonus: A letter about The DJ Who Gave Too Much Information
.
September 22, 2015
Recent awesome Hip Hop by Women
.
Aina More – For People With Short Attention Spans
Lexii Alijai – feel-less
Rapsody – Beauty & The Beast
Leikeli47 – Lk-47 Pt. II
Little Simz – E.D.G.E
Pearls Negras – Biggie Apple Mixtape
Noname – what the fuck is a noname gypsy
Jean Grae – Gotham Down Deluxe
Reverie – The Transition
Karol Conka – Batuk Freak
Chynna – I’m Not Here. This Isn’t Happening
DonMonique – Thirst Trap EP
.
Aina More – For People With Short Attention Spans
Lexii Alijai – feel-less
Rapsody – Beauty & The Beast
Leikeli47 – Lk-47 Pt. II
Little Simz – E.D.G.E
Pearls Negras – Biggie Apple Mixtape
Noname – what the fuck is a noname gypsy
Jean Grae – Gotham Down Deluxe
Reverie – The Transition
Karol Conka – Batuk Freak
Chynna – I’m Not Here. This Isn’t Happening
DonMonique – Thirst Trap EP
.
September 12, 2015
Forty-two Sentences
.
Either you're with us or you're with someone or something else that might be equally worthwhile.
Freedom of speech is most often the freedom to be celebrated for saying things that support the status quo and to be ignored for saying things that challenge it.
Instead of freedom of speech, freedom to establish a more egalitarian alternative to capitalism.
In my two year attempt to write a kind of strange, fictional-autobiography I now realize the block is very simple: I don't want people to know about my life.
Jealousy of other artists is perhaps the most natural part of being an artist.
Artists should have honest discussions about ambition.
Having the courage to be very briefly arrested for your artistic convictions.
If there was no capitalism I would still have desires. But what would they be?
The feeling that I'm trying my best mixed with the feeling that my best isn't actually very good.
Time before clocks.
Christmas is proof that the dominant culture is in fact dominant.
Vulnerable paradoxes.
Mohammad Mosaddegh, Jacobo Árbenz Guzmán, Patrice Lumumba, Salvador Allende.
It is completely possible for an argument to be both brilliant and wrong.
It’s going to get worse before it gets even worse.
Remembering that neoliberalism began not with Thatcher but with Pinochet, and suspecting it will return to its roots.
The best thing to do is apologize, but one should perhaps not already be planning one's apology before one does the bad thing.
It seems everyone needs an other against which to compare, but some of us find this other within.
Markets will self-regulate themselves into ever increasing, more volatile speculative bubbles that sporadically crash.
If there really was a free market it would collapse of its own accord.
When working on a new project, for me the hardest question is always when to fight and when to compromise.
All the artists I admire are such a strange combination of completely open and completely stubborn.
There are already so many books and movies and songs and wars: why make more.
The importance of writing books that are compelling in such a way that they will never be nominated for any awards.
I feel like other writers are trying to write the perfect book while I’m trying to write brilliantly imperfect ones.
I'm hopeless but not without hope.
Reinventing the reinvention of the wheel.
Emotions, one might suggest, are always left unfinished.
During the final game of the world cup, the star player decides to score on his own team's goal as an act of treason.
Solitude versus loneliness.
Desire without expectation.
The assumptions that are in a discipline's blind spot are in fact the same assumptions holding the discipline together.
Money is the lie that makes things possible, so possible we could weep.
Feeling desire is beautiful. But acting on it requires a certain degree of ethical reflection.
If there wasn't a heaven why would anyone bother dying?
Men emotionally recounting how when they were younger they were repeatedly told not to cry.
Posting the same thing over and over again seems, to me, the more I consider the matter, to be the true essence of the internet.
A feeling that the things I'm most interested in generally don't exist.
Keeping art boring in the name of artistic excellence.
Letting things not work.
This feeling that I’ve never been in more intense despair, a feeling I’ve certainly had before.
Racism and sexism are the gasoline of capitalism.
.
Either you're with us or you're with someone or something else that might be equally worthwhile.
Freedom of speech is most often the freedom to be celebrated for saying things that support the status quo and to be ignored for saying things that challenge it.
Instead of freedom of speech, freedom to establish a more egalitarian alternative to capitalism.
In my two year attempt to write a kind of strange, fictional-autobiography I now realize the block is very simple: I don't want people to know about my life.
Jealousy of other artists is perhaps the most natural part of being an artist.
Artists should have honest discussions about ambition.
Having the courage to be very briefly arrested for your artistic convictions.
If there was no capitalism I would still have desires. But what would they be?
The feeling that I'm trying my best mixed with the feeling that my best isn't actually very good.
Time before clocks.
Christmas is proof that the dominant culture is in fact dominant.
Vulnerable paradoxes.
Mohammad Mosaddegh, Jacobo Árbenz Guzmán, Patrice Lumumba, Salvador Allende.
It is completely possible for an argument to be both brilliant and wrong.
It’s going to get worse before it gets even worse.
Remembering that neoliberalism began not with Thatcher but with Pinochet, and suspecting it will return to its roots.
The best thing to do is apologize, but one should perhaps not already be planning one's apology before one does the bad thing.
It seems everyone needs an other against which to compare, but some of us find this other within.
Markets will self-regulate themselves into ever increasing, more volatile speculative bubbles that sporadically crash.
If there really was a free market it would collapse of its own accord.
When working on a new project, for me the hardest question is always when to fight and when to compromise.
All the artists I admire are such a strange combination of completely open and completely stubborn.
There are already so many books and movies and songs and wars: why make more.
The importance of writing books that are compelling in such a way that they will never be nominated for any awards.
I feel like other writers are trying to write the perfect book while I’m trying to write brilliantly imperfect ones.
I'm hopeless but not without hope.
Reinventing the reinvention of the wheel.
Emotions, one might suggest, are always left unfinished.
During the final game of the world cup, the star player decides to score on his own team's goal as an act of treason.
Solitude versus loneliness.
Desire without expectation.
The assumptions that are in a discipline's blind spot are in fact the same assumptions holding the discipline together.
Money is the lie that makes things possible, so possible we could weep.
Feeling desire is beautiful. But acting on it requires a certain degree of ethical reflection.
If there wasn't a heaven why would anyone bother dying?
Men emotionally recounting how when they were younger they were repeatedly told not to cry.
Posting the same thing over and over again seems, to me, the more I consider the matter, to be the true essence of the internet.
A feeling that the things I'm most interested in generally don't exist.
Keeping art boring in the name of artistic excellence.
Letting things not work.
This feeling that I’ve never been in more intense despair, a feeling I’ve certainly had before.
Racism and sexism are the gasoline of capitalism.
.
Labels:
Four Sentences
September 7, 2015
Thirteen quotations on loneliness
.
I don’t believe I’m my own best front (terminal, tie-in, interface): my body, my social bones, what’s on offer there. Rather I want my art (these objects, this language) to be my social body; I believe the art is a better nexus (joint?) to the best parts of me, a realer me. I want to stay home and work – let art do all my talking.
Not unrelated, I always think if I put everything into the work (to the exclusion of all else), the objects that erupt, pullulate by this practice (distillation?) would accordingly be steeped with an ardor such that they would travel into the world and provide people all the love and company and attention I’ve there invested. That making alone would somehow be fully satisfying (qualify as social), and that the exhibition (as some utterly authentic virtual rendezvous) would somehow serve as a thorough modus of loving. In this way practice alone would assuage loneliness and destructive experiences of isolation. It’s a wager I’ve been nursing for decades. (None of this ever seems to work in the way I have planned.)
– Harry Dodge, My Meteorite
The drama of being a loser in the sex selection sweepstakes reveals a confounding irony that is at the center of Houellebecq’s work. You might have been abandoned by your mother (as most of his characters are), indifferently raised, humiliated by your peers; you might be temperamentally aggressive and hostile and feel very little kinship with or interest in most people you meet; you might find true contentment only when you’re alone. In short, you might be thoroughly unsuited for human society. But this will in no way relieve you of the need for other people. You will suffer unbearably from your loneliness, and you will not have any way to fix it.
- Elaine Blair
God knows most of us Americans hate being alone. This may explain why our popular culture is the best in the universe. We keep pouring the cream of our genius and love into producing the antiloneliness serums that are our movies, pop songs, and television shows. We take nothing more seriously than our fun. Well, all of this has been said many times before, often by pundits displaying that other familiar compulsion, to make people feel bad about what makes them human and sociable in whatever way their world allows. Loneliness is no sin. It is “an infinitely gentle, infinitely suffering thing” in need of infinite consolation.
– Peter Schjeldahl
Learn to love solitude, to be more alone with yourselves. The tragedy of today’s young people is that they try to unite on the basis of carrying out noisy and aggressive actions so as not to feel lonely, and this is a sad thing. The individual must learn from childhood to be on his own, for this doesn’t mean to be lonely: it means to not get bored with oneself, because a person who finds himself bored when he is alone, it seems to me, is a person in danger.
- Andrei Tarkovsky on being asked, ‘What would you like to tell young people?’
Loneliness, which is really lack of love, is the pain of being unable to be present, makes us inhabit our bodies differently. At its most radical, loneliness’ pain relates to a missing presence beyond any comprehension or memory, as the speech of what feels the unspeakable. Where it does not, or rather cannot, remain trapped in the self-soothing, heterosexual loops intended for it, it may become a question of political engagement.
- C.E., Undoing Sex: Against Sexual Optimism
Loneliness is the deal. Loneliness is the last great taboo. If we don’t accept loneliness, then capitalism wins hands down. Because capitalism is all about trying to convince people that you can distract yourself, that you can make it better. And it ain’t true.
-Tilda Swinton
So often loneliness comes from being out of touch with parts of oneself. We go searching for those parts in other people, but there’s a difference between feeling separate from others and separate from oneself.
- Diane Ackerman
Suicide is a crime of loneliness, and adulated people can be frighteningly alone. Intelligence does not help in these circumstances; brilliance is almost always profoundly isolating.
- Andrew Solomon
I have been trying, for some time now, to find dignity in my loneliness. I have been finding this hard to do. It is easier, of course, to find dignity in one’s solitude. Loneliness is solitude with a problem.
- Maggie Nelson
So much of our social justice work comes from creating worlds that reflect the opposite of our loneliness.
- KeiyaA
For all the things that we believed / Nothing's ever been achieved / But loneliness, fucking loneliness
- Momus, Loneliness
Solitude can become loneliness; this happens when all by myself I am deserted by my own self.
– Hannah Arendt
Our internal loneliness is echoed by the structural loneliness of society.
- Claudia Rankine
.
I don’t believe I’m my own best front (terminal, tie-in, interface): my body, my social bones, what’s on offer there. Rather I want my art (these objects, this language) to be my social body; I believe the art is a better nexus (joint?) to the best parts of me, a realer me. I want to stay home and work – let art do all my talking.
Not unrelated, I always think if I put everything into the work (to the exclusion of all else), the objects that erupt, pullulate by this practice (distillation?) would accordingly be steeped with an ardor such that they would travel into the world and provide people all the love and company and attention I’ve there invested. That making alone would somehow be fully satisfying (qualify as social), and that the exhibition (as some utterly authentic virtual rendezvous) would somehow serve as a thorough modus of loving. In this way practice alone would assuage loneliness and destructive experiences of isolation. It’s a wager I’ve been nursing for decades. (None of this ever seems to work in the way I have planned.)
– Harry Dodge, My Meteorite
The drama of being a loser in the sex selection sweepstakes reveals a confounding irony that is at the center of Houellebecq’s work. You might have been abandoned by your mother (as most of his characters are), indifferently raised, humiliated by your peers; you might be temperamentally aggressive and hostile and feel very little kinship with or interest in most people you meet; you might find true contentment only when you’re alone. In short, you might be thoroughly unsuited for human society. But this will in no way relieve you of the need for other people. You will suffer unbearably from your loneliness, and you will not have any way to fix it.
- Elaine Blair
God knows most of us Americans hate being alone. This may explain why our popular culture is the best in the universe. We keep pouring the cream of our genius and love into producing the antiloneliness serums that are our movies, pop songs, and television shows. We take nothing more seriously than our fun. Well, all of this has been said many times before, often by pundits displaying that other familiar compulsion, to make people feel bad about what makes them human and sociable in whatever way their world allows. Loneliness is no sin. It is “an infinitely gentle, infinitely suffering thing” in need of infinite consolation.
– Peter Schjeldahl
Learn to love solitude, to be more alone with yourselves. The tragedy of today’s young people is that they try to unite on the basis of carrying out noisy and aggressive actions so as not to feel lonely, and this is a sad thing. The individual must learn from childhood to be on his own, for this doesn’t mean to be lonely: it means to not get bored with oneself, because a person who finds himself bored when he is alone, it seems to me, is a person in danger.
- Andrei Tarkovsky on being asked, ‘What would you like to tell young people?’
Loneliness, which is really lack of love, is the pain of being unable to be present, makes us inhabit our bodies differently. At its most radical, loneliness’ pain relates to a missing presence beyond any comprehension or memory, as the speech of what feels the unspeakable. Where it does not, or rather cannot, remain trapped in the self-soothing, heterosexual loops intended for it, it may become a question of political engagement.
- C.E., Undoing Sex: Against Sexual Optimism
Loneliness is the deal. Loneliness is the last great taboo. If we don’t accept loneliness, then capitalism wins hands down. Because capitalism is all about trying to convince people that you can distract yourself, that you can make it better. And it ain’t true.
-Tilda Swinton
So often loneliness comes from being out of touch with parts of oneself. We go searching for those parts in other people, but there’s a difference between feeling separate from others and separate from oneself.
- Diane Ackerman
Suicide is a crime of loneliness, and adulated people can be frighteningly alone. Intelligence does not help in these circumstances; brilliance is almost always profoundly isolating.
- Andrew Solomon
I have been trying, for some time now, to find dignity in my loneliness. I have been finding this hard to do. It is easier, of course, to find dignity in one’s solitude. Loneliness is solitude with a problem.
- Maggie Nelson
So much of our social justice work comes from creating worlds that reflect the opposite of our loneliness.
- KeiyaA
For all the things that we believed / Nothing's ever been achieved / But loneliness, fucking loneliness
- Momus, Loneliness
Solitude can become loneliness; this happens when all by myself I am deserted by my own self.
– Hannah Arendt
Our internal loneliness is echoed by the structural loneliness of society.
- Claudia Rankine
.
Labels:
Loneliness,
Quotations On,
Quotes
September 6, 2015
Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha Quote
.
This border is rotten meat, a hallucination, a wavering line
a stupid idea. Can't we blink and it'll be gone?
- Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha, Bodymap
.
This border is rotten meat, a hallucination, a wavering line
a stupid idea. Can't we blink and it'll be gone?
- Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha, Bodymap
.
Labels:
Leah Lakshmi Piepzna-Samarasinha,
Quotes
September 2, 2015
Waiting Poem (First Draft)
.
I’m trying to figure things out but I’m not figuring things out, unable to separate my thoughts from my feelings from the things I have utterly and totally wrong. It all folds together in one long unfigured mush. After I die they can dissect this mush and find the tumor. Someone will decide if this tumor is a thought, idea or feeling and someone else can decide that they’re wrong. They might decide to argue about it or decide it’s simply not worth the bother. But for now I am still alive, trying to figure things out, searching for where to start, or what might be the beginning and what might be the end. Having a beginning or an end might be a start. A crime scene needs a clue, a culprit, a verdict, but more than any of these things it needs a judge. When I get sad I want to blame someone and I want that someone to blame myself. I don’t know what the point is of publishing books after you die but I know there is often an increase in demand. When posthumous demand decreases we might think of it as a different kind of success. And then there is this chronic hacking cough, the most literal thing I am currently trying to figure out. Everyone thinks they are my friend but I am forced to admit I don’t think of them in quite the same way. Let’s let differences remain different! Or let’s not and say we did! Last summer I was sad and this summer is similar but different. How are we to understand a pain that won’t let us ever quite escape? How many pages have I written or will I write before I die? Too many and, what’s more, too few. A sinking feeling that is almost criminal? I am trying to figure things out but in the grip of a terrible unfiguring. Before I had no readership but now I have only the readership that will hate these words. There are so many of us who all agree, who want to replace literature with telepathy. And if we can agree on that I am certain we can agree on so many wonderful things. Do you want to read the first three pages of a possible new book and let me know what you think? Past page fifteen I have the terrible, awful, horrible feeling that there is no turning back. I am trying to turn back, figure things out, learn where I went wrong. Each fork in the road is a devastating lie regarding the nature of choice. Things come too easy to me and it is all unbearably hard. But keep going, we keep going, as each step demands and falls in love with yet another step. This is the true nature of time. Different shades of waiting and different calamities of time. When you turn against things they turn towards you, and again, turn into step after delicate step. One of the words I have been using far too often in my writing is the word tears. This word is like so many words, an appointment I probably should have cancelled. This word is like a secret that is also the exact opposite of a secret, a secret place. A secret that needs editing and will always remain unedited. Crying as you write the word tears.
.
I’m trying to figure things out but I’m not figuring things out, unable to separate my thoughts from my feelings from the things I have utterly and totally wrong. It all folds together in one long unfigured mush. After I die they can dissect this mush and find the tumor. Someone will decide if this tumor is a thought, idea or feeling and someone else can decide that they’re wrong. They might decide to argue about it or decide it’s simply not worth the bother. But for now I am still alive, trying to figure things out, searching for where to start, or what might be the beginning and what might be the end. Having a beginning or an end might be a start. A crime scene needs a clue, a culprit, a verdict, but more than any of these things it needs a judge. When I get sad I want to blame someone and I want that someone to blame myself. I don’t know what the point is of publishing books after you die but I know there is often an increase in demand. When posthumous demand decreases we might think of it as a different kind of success. And then there is this chronic hacking cough, the most literal thing I am currently trying to figure out. Everyone thinks they are my friend but I am forced to admit I don’t think of them in quite the same way. Let’s let differences remain different! Or let’s not and say we did! Last summer I was sad and this summer is similar but different. How are we to understand a pain that won’t let us ever quite escape? How many pages have I written or will I write before I die? Too many and, what’s more, too few. A sinking feeling that is almost criminal? I am trying to figure things out but in the grip of a terrible unfiguring. Before I had no readership but now I have only the readership that will hate these words. There are so many of us who all agree, who want to replace literature with telepathy. And if we can agree on that I am certain we can agree on so many wonderful things. Do you want to read the first three pages of a possible new book and let me know what you think? Past page fifteen I have the terrible, awful, horrible feeling that there is no turning back. I am trying to turn back, figure things out, learn where I went wrong. Each fork in the road is a devastating lie regarding the nature of choice. Things come too easy to me and it is all unbearably hard. But keep going, we keep going, as each step demands and falls in love with yet another step. This is the true nature of time. Different shades of waiting and different calamities of time. When you turn against things they turn towards you, and again, turn into step after delicate step. One of the words I have been using far too often in my writing is the word tears. This word is like so many words, an appointment I probably should have cancelled. This word is like a secret that is also the exact opposite of a secret, a secret place. A secret that needs editing and will always remain unedited. Crying as you write the word tears.
.
Labels:
A poem by Jacob Wren
August 31, 2015
Health Problems
.
This isn't fiction. I am writing about this here and now because it is something not everyone knows about me and I often wonder if this is a mistake. I always feel that I'm an open book, but I also think I constantly find ways of being an open book that are actually quite secretive. As an artist, this might even be said to be on of my virtues. But that's not what I'll be writing about today.
I have had more or less the same health problems for the past thirty years, and at times it seems to me they have been getting incrementally worse for that entire time. These days I am in so much pain I am barely able to function, but for the most part I manage to function anyways.
At the same time, even though I have been in this pain for so long, I still don't really know what it is, what causes it, or what the best treatments might be. I would say starting at some point, maybe about ten years ago, I have simply tried to ignore my health problems to the best of my ability. Unsurprisingly, over this period the pain has steadily worsened.
I've never been able to get a diagnoses to prove it, but I feel my health problems are somewhere in the realm of chronic fatigue syndrome or fibromyalgia. But, then again, maybe not. Maybe my understanding of what ails me is way off base and therefore hindering my ability to seek improvement. But the more general description chronic pain would be difficult to undermine.
The right side of my body hurts much more than the left side. The pain in the right side of my body seems to emanate out from my right hip. But I also wonder if the pain in my hip comes from some sort of slight twist in my lower small intestine. Or if there is a relationship between the hip and the intestine that prevents either one from fully releasing. It is also possible that the problem originates with my gait, that my right foot doesn't land correctly and therefore keeps the right side of my body twisted. At any rate, these are all either symptoms or origins of the pain I've been in for the past thirty years. I also have regular headaches. And lately there has been a fair bit of nausea.
A more recent problem, that's maybe started around five years ago, is a chronic cough along with difficulty breathing. This cough has gotten much worse in the past six weeks and perhaps has inspired me to write this post. My understanding is that my rib cage pushes forward and presses into my lungs. I'm also not sure if this is a correct diagnoses.
About ten years ago, when I was more often seeking treatment, I found I couldn't actually get myself to do anything the doctors or health practitioners suggested. I would go for the appointments, listen carefully to everything they said I should do, and then do none of it. After awhile of this it was only a short step to no longer seeking help. At the forefront of my mind throughout this pathetic comedy was that if I did their suggestions I might live longer, and mainly what I wanted was to die as soon as possible. Obviously, there is a very intense and intimate relationship between my health problems and my considerable depression. Maybe my more severe depression started around the same time as my health problems, but I have always has a melancholy temperament.
However, I do still do a few things to take the edge off the pain: acupuncture, osteopathy and I also wear orthotics to partially correctly my walk. All of these things help a little, but as the years roll on they seem to be helping less and less.
I often write about my depression but I rarely write about my health problems. I think the reason for this is I do suspect there are things I could do to at least slightly improve my health but for the most part I don't do them. I am ashamed of my continued inaction. Sometimes I feel it reflects a deeper truth about me, that I don't really want to live, that I am living my life as if it were an extremely slow and aggravating suicide. (For example, I eat poorly and get no exercise.) At other times I feel there is no real truth in it. That I simply didn't manage to figure out the root of the problem and after awhile gave up trying. This is the opposite of what one should do in activism, and I am obviously an extremely poor activist for my own health.
But, when I write about how awful the world is, I often feel that perhaps I wouldn't find it as awful if I wasn't in constant, almost unbearable pain, and hadn't been for the last thirty years. And I worry that this skews my outlook as an artist, and of course also my more general outlook on life. There is so much defeatism in my work and thinking, and it seems a bit too obvious that this outlook is related to my defeat in the face ongoing physical pain. I so often wonder what life is like for other people.
.
This isn't fiction. I am writing about this here and now because it is something not everyone knows about me and I often wonder if this is a mistake. I always feel that I'm an open book, but I also think I constantly find ways of being an open book that are actually quite secretive. As an artist, this might even be said to be on of my virtues. But that's not what I'll be writing about today.
I have had more or less the same health problems for the past thirty years, and at times it seems to me they have been getting incrementally worse for that entire time. These days I am in so much pain I am barely able to function, but for the most part I manage to function anyways.
At the same time, even though I have been in this pain for so long, I still don't really know what it is, what causes it, or what the best treatments might be. I would say starting at some point, maybe about ten years ago, I have simply tried to ignore my health problems to the best of my ability. Unsurprisingly, over this period the pain has steadily worsened.
I've never been able to get a diagnoses to prove it, but I feel my health problems are somewhere in the realm of chronic fatigue syndrome or fibromyalgia. But, then again, maybe not. Maybe my understanding of what ails me is way off base and therefore hindering my ability to seek improvement. But the more general description chronic pain would be difficult to undermine.
The right side of my body hurts much more than the left side. The pain in the right side of my body seems to emanate out from my right hip. But I also wonder if the pain in my hip comes from some sort of slight twist in my lower small intestine. Or if there is a relationship between the hip and the intestine that prevents either one from fully releasing. It is also possible that the problem originates with my gait, that my right foot doesn't land correctly and therefore keeps the right side of my body twisted. At any rate, these are all either symptoms or origins of the pain I've been in for the past thirty years. I also have regular headaches. And lately there has been a fair bit of nausea.
A more recent problem, that's maybe started around five years ago, is a chronic cough along with difficulty breathing. This cough has gotten much worse in the past six weeks and perhaps has inspired me to write this post. My understanding is that my rib cage pushes forward and presses into my lungs. I'm also not sure if this is a correct diagnoses.
About ten years ago, when I was more often seeking treatment, I found I couldn't actually get myself to do anything the doctors or health practitioners suggested. I would go for the appointments, listen carefully to everything they said I should do, and then do none of it. After awhile of this it was only a short step to no longer seeking help. At the forefront of my mind throughout this pathetic comedy was that if I did their suggestions I might live longer, and mainly what I wanted was to die as soon as possible. Obviously, there is a very intense and intimate relationship between my health problems and my considerable depression. Maybe my more severe depression started around the same time as my health problems, but I have always has a melancholy temperament.
However, I do still do a few things to take the edge off the pain: acupuncture, osteopathy and I also wear orthotics to partially correctly my walk. All of these things help a little, but as the years roll on they seem to be helping less and less.
I often write about my depression but I rarely write about my health problems. I think the reason for this is I do suspect there are things I could do to at least slightly improve my health but for the most part I don't do them. I am ashamed of my continued inaction. Sometimes I feel it reflects a deeper truth about me, that I don't really want to live, that I am living my life as if it were an extremely slow and aggravating suicide. (For example, I eat poorly and get no exercise.) At other times I feel there is no real truth in it. That I simply didn't manage to figure out the root of the problem and after awhile gave up trying. This is the opposite of what one should do in activism, and I am obviously an extremely poor activist for my own health.
But, when I write about how awful the world is, I often feel that perhaps I wouldn't find it as awful if I wasn't in constant, almost unbearable pain, and hadn't been for the last thirty years. And I worry that this skews my outlook as an artist, and of course also my more general outlook on life. There is so much defeatism in my work and thinking, and it seems a bit too obvious that this outlook is related to my defeat in the face ongoing physical pain. I so often wonder what life is like for other people.
.
August 28, 2015
Yes and No
.
For the past six weeks I've been saying no to all work offers, saying that I can't take on anything new until I've finished my next book. Every time I say no to anything I almost feel like I've committed a crime. Makes me realize the degree to which I've programmed myself over the past twenty-five years to say yes to everything.
.
For the past six weeks I've been saying no to all work offers, saying that I can't take on anything new until I've finished my next book. Every time I say no to anything I almost feel like I've committed a crime. Makes me realize the degree to which I've programmed myself over the past twenty-five years to say yes to everything.
.
August 23, 2015
Two Kristin Ross Quotes
.
"The logic of emancipation concerned concrete relations between individuals. The logic of the institution, on the other hand, is always nothing more than the indefinite reproduction of itself. Emancipation is not the result but the condition for instruction."
"Time or temporality is a human, social construction, and as such is tainted by the contemporary biases and dominant prejudices of the moment - such as the idea that dominates our own time that one should accumulate the most capital one can, hoard it to oneself, and then die."
- Both quotes from Communal Luxury: The Political Imaginary of the Paris Commune by Kristin Ross
.
"The logic of emancipation concerned concrete relations between individuals. The logic of the institution, on the other hand, is always nothing more than the indefinite reproduction of itself. Emancipation is not the result but the condition for instruction."
"Time or temporality is a human, social construction, and as such is tainted by the contemporary biases and dominant prejudices of the moment - such as the idea that dominates our own time that one should accumulate the most capital one can, hoard it to oneself, and then die."
- Both quotes from Communal Luxury: The Political Imaginary of the Paris Commune by Kristin Ross
.
Labels:
Kristen Ross,
Quotes
August 8, 2015
Ten Years
.
I have now been doing A Radical Cut in the Texture of Reality for ten years. The first post was on August 8, 2005. As I recently wrote:
When I started my blog almost ten years ago, the main reason was that I was struggling with writers block. I was tired of sending my writing out to publishers and having it rejected, or accepted but with alterations that frequently made it feel less like my own. I would think about the various publishing opportunities open to me and it would kill at least some of my desire to write anything new. And then, suddenly, with this blog I could write just a few sentences and put them out into the world immediately. It didn’t have to be the greatest thing I had ever written. It could simply be a chance for a few interested readers to see my working process, and if they liked it to encourage me with their comments. To try things out and learn through doing.
In this sense A Radical Cut has been about as effective a thing in my work life as I am able to imagine. When I started ten years ago I had almost completely stopped writing, and somehow all this got me going again, put a few of my words out into the world where they could be both criticized and encouraged. I'm not sure I would have written any of the books I've written over the past ten years if I didn't also have this forum to share things as they went, to pursue dead ends in public and to see what my thoughts looked and felt like when I shared them online.
Ten years is a long time to do something and I wanted to somehow mark the occasion. So far this is all I've come up with. I wonder if I'll manage another ten...
.
Lacan is not this kind of poet of failure. The truly traumatic thing is that miracles – not in the religious sense but in the sense of free acts – do happen, but it’s very difficult to come to terms with them. So we should reject this idea of a poetry of failure. For Lacan, Real is not this kind of Thing-in-itself that we cannot approach; Real is, rather, freedom as a radical cut in the texture of reality.
– Slavoj Žižek, from Conversations with Zizek
I have now been doing A Radical Cut in the Texture of Reality for ten years. The first post was on August 8, 2005. As I recently wrote:
When I started my blog almost ten years ago, the main reason was that I was struggling with writers block. I was tired of sending my writing out to publishers and having it rejected, or accepted but with alterations that frequently made it feel less like my own. I would think about the various publishing opportunities open to me and it would kill at least some of my desire to write anything new. And then, suddenly, with this blog I could write just a few sentences and put them out into the world immediately. It didn’t have to be the greatest thing I had ever written. It could simply be a chance for a few interested readers to see my working process, and if they liked it to encourage me with their comments. To try things out and learn through doing.
In this sense A Radical Cut has been about as effective a thing in my work life as I am able to imagine. When I started ten years ago I had almost completely stopped writing, and somehow all this got me going again, put a few of my words out into the world where they could be both criticized and encouraged. I'm not sure I would have written any of the books I've written over the past ten years if I didn't also have this forum to share things as they went, to pursue dead ends in public and to see what my thoughts looked and felt like when I shared them online.
Ten years is a long time to do something and I wanted to somehow mark the occasion. So far this is all I've come up with. I wonder if I'll manage another ten...
.
July 30, 2015
“Better late than later.”
.
I've been thinking about this paragraph:
(It's part of the conclusion of Carl Pope's article: Get Ready for Ugly as "Free Markets" Begin to Deal With Climate Crisis.)
1915 was one hundred years ago. Is it possible that by 2040 oil will seem like a thing of the past?
There is this feeling that things are moving too slowly, or not at all. But, at the same time, I also have the feeling that when things do change sometimes they can switch really fast, like rats fleeing a sinking ship.
I don't think this change will in any way save us. Wars over oil will be replaced by wars over water. And the environmental degradation that is already underway will bring along with it more flooding, hurricanes, typhoons, migration, famine, disease, mass species extinctions and, as previously mentioned, war. But if oil were to become out of bounds, or even greatly reduced, in my lifetime it would be really be something to see.
The phrase “Better late than later.” comes from a Christiana Figueres speech. And whenever I hear people say 'It's already too late' I think the exact opposite is true in any given situation. The true motto of all activism is that there is always something to be done, it is never too late. And you don't yet know what is or isn't possible until it happens.
Arthur Ashe: "Start where you are. Use what you have. Do what you can."
Albert Camus: "One must imagine Sisyphus happy."
+ + + +
As an addendum I thought I'd return to a section from an earlier post entitled Stories I started but couldn't finish:
.
I've been thinking about this paragraph:
In 1915, as the American economy boomed, the huge supply chain that supported horse-drawn transport—harnesses and horseshoes, wagons and buggies makers (13,000 of them), farriers and blacksmiths, hay balers and feedmills—looked like a robust and vital segment for deploying capital. 1920 was the year of “Peak Horse” in the U.S.. By 1940 it was gone. This was not “low-cost”, incremental progress. It was an economic disruption so fierce that the phrase “buggy-whip maker” became a business simile for loser.
(It's part of the conclusion of Carl Pope's article: Get Ready for Ugly as "Free Markets" Begin to Deal With Climate Crisis.)
1915 was one hundred years ago. Is it possible that by 2040 oil will seem like a thing of the past?
There is this feeling that things are moving too slowly, or not at all. But, at the same time, I also have the feeling that when things do change sometimes they can switch really fast, like rats fleeing a sinking ship.
I don't think this change will in any way save us. Wars over oil will be replaced by wars over water. And the environmental degradation that is already underway will bring along with it more flooding, hurricanes, typhoons, migration, famine, disease, mass species extinctions and, as previously mentioned, war. But if oil were to become out of bounds, or even greatly reduced, in my lifetime it would be really be something to see.
The phrase “Better late than later.” comes from a Christiana Figueres speech. And whenever I hear people say 'It's already too late' I think the exact opposite is true in any given situation. The true motto of all activism is that there is always something to be done, it is never too late. And you don't yet know what is or isn't possible until it happens.
Arthur Ashe: "Start where you are. Use what you have. Do what you can."
Albert Camus: "One must imagine Sisyphus happy."
+ + + +
As an addendum I thought I'd return to a section from an earlier post entitled Stories I started but couldn't finish:
I have been thinking so much about solar energy, about how much of what I read, especially from a mainstream perspective, seems misplaced. When I read that we will not be able to generate enough energy using solar and wind, I feel they are completely missing the point. The points are:
1) That these new, sustainable technologies will force us to use less, will demonstrate – on a real, lived, experiential basis – that resources are renewable but not infinite.
2) That there is more autonomy, and less greedy profit, in a decentralized power grid.
3) That the many exorbitant expenses of polluting the air and water are simply not being factored into the standard calculations. Environmental devastation is expensive on every level.
But it is mainly the first point I obsess over. Let’s say you have solar panels on the roof of your house. Each day, you will use only as much energy as these panels generate. When it runs out you go to sleep and wait for the sun to come up tomorrow. The energy is not infinite, not available twenty-four hours a day. There are limits and you learn, out of necessity, how to live within them.
This, for me, is the main lesson of sustainable technologies. They would force us to live differently, to be aware of daily limits, to find solutions that acknowledge real limitations. They do not make life easier in every way. They make life harder in some ways, ways that force a fundamental shift in how we see the world and our place within it. I also suspect that working within a series of concrete, reasonable limitations would bring along with it a kind of reality and even joy.
.
Labels:
Albert Camus,
Arthur Ashe,
Carl Pope,
Christiana Figueres,
Oil,
Solar Energy
July 29, 2015
Renee Gladman Quote
.
"I wrote a book whose title I withheld from the book for a long time as I wrote it and slept on it and not because I didn’t want the book to know itself (I had no influence on that), rather, because I feared that once I put the two together they would go on without me."
- Renee Gladman, Ana Patova Crosses A Bridge
.
"I wrote a book whose title I withheld from the book for a long time as I wrote it and slept on it and not because I didn’t want the book to know itself (I had no influence on that), rather, because I feared that once I put the two together they would go on without me."
- Renee Gladman, Ana Patova Crosses A Bridge
.
Labels:
Quotes,
Renee Gladman
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
